Editorial
High prevalence of renal dysfunction also
after small bowel transplantation
Renal dysfunction after pediatric solid organ
transplantation
Solid organ transplantation is the therapy of
choice for end-stage solid organ disease, espe-
cially in children. As rejection rates are improv-
ing, much of the focus after pediatric solid organ
transplantation is shifting toward the identifica-
tion and prevention of collateral damage such as
nephrotoxicity (1, 2). Ojo et al. taught us about
the high prevalence of chronic kidney disease
(CKD) in all non-renal adult solid organ trans-
plant recipients (3, 4). CKD is a major cause of
morbidity and mortality after non-renal trans-
plantation (5). Renal damage is best studied by
monitoring glomerular filtration rate (GFR, 6).
GFR should be measured using appropriate
clearance studies or at least using cystatin C
(7, 8). Cystatin C is a low molecular weight
protein that measures GFR reliably and indepen-
dent of body composition (9). Using calculated
GFR such as the Schwartz formula, creatinine
clearance or the serum creatinine level will lead
to an overestimation of GFR (10, 11).
Pediatric Transplantation recently published a
number of studies on the prevalence of CKD in
solid organ transplantation in children. Progres-
sive worsening of GFR was demonstrated in
heart-transplanted children (12). Bharat’s manu-
script also demonstrated a high degree of under-
estimation of the degree of CKD when using the
Schwartz formula. Feingold et al. (13) provided
additional insights from a multi-institutional
database of pediatric heart transplant recipients
by carefully analyzing risk factors for late renal
dysfunction after pediatric heart transplantation.
The study highlighted the importance of moni-
toring and managing low GFR after one yr of
transplantation (13, 14). In Feingold’s study,
1.4% of heart transplant children became dialysis
dependent after a median follow-up of only
4.1 yr, and most certainly that number will
increase with longer follow-up. Clearly, identifying
and managing CKD is of high importance as
identifying and managing CKD early may help
to reduce morbidity (1), and if done well, decline
of GFR can be slowed significantly (15).
In 2010, there also was a report on large liver
transplant registry, which reported on a large
data set with a cross-sectional study of 397
patients (16). In that study, 11% of patients had
CKD stage 2 or worse (GFR below 90 mL/min/
1.73 m
2
) at the time of transplantation (16).
Among the remaining 333 patients, 52 (15.6)%
with initially normal renal function developed
abnormally low GFR at a mean follow-up of
5.2 yr (16). Kivela also reported a high preva-
lence of CKD after orthotopic liver trans-
plantation in children with cyclosporin
immunosuppression (17). A recent longitudinal
study from Geneva of 24 pediatric liver trans-
plant recipients on tacrolimus suggests that the
prevalence of CKD may not be related to the
choice of the calcineurin inhibitor (18). In this
cohort, 39% of patients had a GFR <90 mL/
min/1.73 m
2
at the time of transplantation. The
particular strength of Stelle’s study is its longitu-
dinal nature and the inclusion of other nephro-
logical parameters such as proteinuria and
hypertension (19). Interestingly, albeit that ta-
crolimus-related nephrotoxicity is considered as
the etiological factor for the development of pro-
gressive CKD (20), there was no correlation
between the tacrolimus exposure (measured as
trough level) and the measured GFR in the study
from Geneva (18). The etiology of the CKD is
probably multifactorial.
CKD in small bowel transplant patients
Olivia Boyer et al.’s (21) study now adds to the
literature and describes renal function and even
renal histology in pediatric small bowel trans-
plant recipients in this issue of Pediatric Trans-
plantation. Boyer et al. studied 15 combined
liver/small bowel transplant recipients and 12
8
Pediatr Transplantation 2013: 17: 8–11
© 2012 John Wiley & Sons A/S.
Pediatric Transplantation
DOI: 10.1111/petr.12025