Labyrinth Dysfunction 8 Months After Cochlear
Implantation: A Case Report
*John-Martin Hempel, †Lorenz Jäger, *Uwe Baumann, *Eike Krause, and *Gerd Rasp
*Ear Nose and Throat Clinic and the †Institute of Clinical Radiology, Ludwig Maximilians University,
Munich, Germany
Objective: Investigate whether the cochleostomy is a possible
port of entry for pneumolabyrinth and a resulting vertigo in
patients provided with a cochlear implant.
Study Design: Retrospective case review.
Setting: Ludwig-Maximilians University of Munich, Hospital
Grosshadern.
Patient: 62-year-old patient who underwent implantation of a
HiFocus II cochlear implant with positioner from Advanced
Bionics (CLARION). Eight months postoperatively, the patient
reported rotatory vertigo and right-side tinnitus after he had
blown his nose harder than usual during an episode of rhinitis.
Interventions: Preoperative and postoperative testing of both
the petrosal bone with a CT scan and of balance function.
Main Outcome Measure: Air inclusion in the labyrinth.
Results: In contrast to the preoperative high resolution com-
puted tomography (CT) scan, air inclusion was seen in the
labyrinth during the episode of vertigo. At the same time, bal-
ance function tests with Frenzel glasses revealed both sponta-
neous and provoked horizontal nystagmus to the right side. At
follow-up 8 weeks later, the level of vertigo had significantly
decreased. Twelve months later, the control CT showed the
cochlear implant positioned correctly and no visible air in the
labyrinth.
Conclusion: It is known that placement of the HiFocus II with
Positioner from CLARION requires a relatively large cochleo-
stomy of 1.5 mm. Moreover, in the connective tissue seal be-
tween the electrode and the positioner, the latter reaches into
the tympanic cavity, and this is possibly the weak point. Further
investigation will be needed to determine whether the large
cochleostomy with the HiFocus II with positioner increases the
predisposition to labyrinth dysfunction. Key Words: Cochlea
implantation—Labyrinth dysfunction—Vertigo.
Otol Neurotol 25:727–729, 2004.
Patients frequently complain of disturbances of bal-
ance after cochlear implantation. According to the litera-
ture, the incidence is between 0% and 60% (1–5). Kubo
et al. (3) has classified disturbances of balance according
to when they appear after surgery. The first group com-
prises patients who have disturbed balance immediately
after surgery. Symptoms usually disappear within 1
month. Characteristically, the vertigo is of short duration
and is provoked by head movement. The second group of
patients has persistent disturbances of balance lasting for
more than 6 months after the surgical procedure. The
final group contains patients who develop symptoms of
vertigo at least 1 month after surgery, so-called “delayed
vertigo” (3). According to Kubo et al. (3), the vertigo in
these patients is usually idiopathic and is longer lasting.
Delayed vertigo occurred in 15 of 94 cases reported by
Kubo et al. (3). The likely etiology was meningitis in one
of 15 cases and ototoxicity in two of 15 cases. The eti-
ology was unknown in 12 patients (3). Fina et al. (5) just
published data from a retrospective analysis of patients
receiving a cochlear implantation. They also differenti-
ated between early and late onset (>24 hours after im-
plantation) of the dizziness and reported, in the type of
early onset, recovering within 3 days (four of 29 pa-
tients). They discussed labyrinthitis as a possible cause.
Most of the patients (25 of 29) reported a late onset of
vertigo (median time, 74 days) (5).
Risk factors of vertigo after cochlea implantation include:
1. Preimplantation vestibular symptoms, especially
Ménière’s disease (5);
2. Age at implantation greater than 59 years old (5); and
3. Age at onset of hearing loss greater than 26 years
old (5).
Other possible causes of vertigo after cochlear implan-
tation include:
1. Perilymph fistula caused by the cochleostomy;
2. Direct trauma resulting from positioning of the
electrode in the labyrinth; and
3. Conduction of electrical potentials originating in
the cochlear implant into the balance organ (6).
CASE REPORT
A 62-year-old patient underwent implantation of a
HiFocus II cochlear implant with positioner from Ad-
vanced Bionics (CLARION; Rixheim, France) in the
right ear at the age of 61 years because of severe bilateral
inner ear deafness. The patient was one of six in whom
we used the HiFocus II cochlear implant. The total num-
ber of cochlear implantation is on average 30 a year,
surgery being performed by the same surgeon.
The deafness was of early childhood onset, assumed to
be the result of asphyxia during birth. There were no
other risk factors for early childhood-acquired or heredi-
tary deafness. There was no history or evidence on clini-
Address correspondence and reprint requests to J. M. Hempel, M.D.,
Klinik für Hals-, Nasen- und Ohrenheilkunde, der Ludwig-
Maximilians-Universität München, Marchioninistrasse 15, 81377
München, Germany; Email: John-Martin.Hempel@med.uni-muenchen.de
Otology & Neurotology
25:727–729 © 2004, Otology & Neurotology, Inc.
727