International Journal of Water Resources and Environmental Engineering Vol. 3(12), pp. 288-297, 21 November, 2011
Available online at http://www.academicjournals.org/ijwree
DOI: 10.5897/IJWREE11.067
ISSN 1991-637X ©2011 Academic Journals
Full Length Research Paper
Selection of optimum option for sludge disposal in the
Guilan province of Iran using rapid impact assessment
matrix (RIAM)
Aghil Golipour Shoili
1
, Mehrdad Farrokhi
1
*, Hadi Neizehbaz
2
and Hoseyn Alizadeh
2
1
Guilan University of Medical Sciences, School of Health, Rasht, Guilan Iran.
2
Guilan Water and Wastewater Company, TSU, Rasht, Guilan, Iran.
Accepted 21 October, 2011
All wastewater treatment processes produce a large amount of semisolid pollutants, especially
wastewater sludge. Discharge of sludge without environmental considerations will have many serious
effects on public health and environment. The main objective of this study is the selection of optimum
option for sludge disposal in the Guilan province of Iran using rapid impact assessment matrix (RIAM)
which is a tool to organise, analyse and present the results of a holistic environmental impact analysis
(EIA). The effects of five options of sludge disposal (sludge composting, co-composting, grass land
application, sanitary landfill and incineration) on four environmental components (physical-chemical,
biological-ecological, social and economical) are evaluated via questionnaires which were was
addressed to all environmental experts in water and wastewater companies in Guilan province. It was
found that there are different optimum options for each environmental component. Based on overall
comparison of the options' effects on all the components, the analysis of matrices has shown that co-
composting is the best recommended option for sludge disposal in the existing conditions.
Key words: Sludge disposal, environmental impact assessment (EIA), rapid impact assessment matrix (RAIM),
Guilan province, environmental components.
INTRODUCTION
All wastewater treatment processes produce a large
amount of semisolid pollutants, especially wastewater
sludge. Sludge from wastewater treatment is a
concentrated liquid, with characteristics that vary
according to the type of plant and method of operation.
The solid concentration in sludge varies between 1 to 6%
by weight (Turovskiy and Mathai, 2006). The treatment
and disposal of sludge are two of the most important and
complex subjects in wastewater engineering. Discharge
of sludge without proper treatment will have many serious
effects on public health and environment. Therefore,
sludge should be treated before being discharged into the
environment. In selecting the appropriate methods for
sludge processing, disposal and reuse, considerations
must be given to the relevant standards and regulation
(Iran EPA, 2005).
*Corresponding author. mfarokhikhb@yahoo.com.
The Guilan province is located in southern side of the
Caspian Sea. In this province, there are various
internationally registered natural resources such as
wetlands, lakes, rivers, forests, etc. Improper sludge
discharge can have adverse effects on these natural
resources and public health (Farrokhi et al., 2008). There
are three sludge treatment plants in the cities of Rasht
and Anzali that at the present produce 40 m3/day of
dewatered sludge (GWWC, 2010). Non proper sludge
disposal can have adversely affects on these natural
resources and public health (Farrokhi et al., 2008). The
choice of a sludge disposal system should be based on
their environmental effects (Poulsen and Hansen 2003).
Different environmental impact assessment (EIA)
methods are used for sludge management technologies
for example Life Cycle Assessment method used to
compare different options for sludge treatment and so as
to determine which option is the most environmentally
sound (Ngelah and Per, 2008). The main objective of
this study is to conduct the selection of optimum option