Text Copying as a Culture-Based Learning
Strategy: A Case of EFL Grammar Learners in an
Arabic Context
Mohammad R. Alnufaie
English Language Institute, Royal Commission for Jubail and Yanbu, Saudi Arabia
Abstract—As a well-established strategy in the educational traditions of Islam, copying texts (imitating a model)
has played a crucial role in learning the Holy Quran and the Arabic language. This study delves into the
necessity of understanding how this traditional strategy influences the learning of foreign languages. Using 18
hours of strategy-based instruction, this paper examines the efficacy of text copying in learning grammar
(independent variable), as evidenced by a series of grammar tests and surveys assessing learners’ perceptions
(dependent variables). The study draws upon data from two groups of college-level English as Foreign
Language (EFL) learners, comprising a control group (n=10) and an experimental group (n=11), all
categorized at the A2 proficiency level according to the Common European Framework of Reference for
Languages (CEFR). The findings suggest that text copying enhances learners’ grammatical understanding and
contributes to overall satisfaction in learning a foreign language, as indicated by improved test scores and
positive learner feedback.
Index Terms—text copying, grammar learning strategies, strategy instruction, repetition
I. INTRODUCTION
Developing conscious and unconscious mechanisms is a critical component of strategic learning so humans can
process, remember, and acquire information and skills in various fields (Pressley & Harris, 2006). Since individuals
encounter various tasks and approaches, assuming they will discover and apply all the necessary strategies is difficult.
Researchers, therefore, emphasize the importance of strategy instruction for strategies to be adopted effectively
(Pressley & Harris, 2006; Plonsky, 2011, 2019).
Taking Vygotsky’s sociocultural perspective on learning, this study presents text copying as a strategy that enhances
grammar learning and stimulates learners toward better learning through crucial, meaningful, and transformational
experiences. In Vygotsky’s sociocultural theory and its Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD), imitation is a way of
social learning that is far from the old thinking of imitation as a mere act of habit formation. “The view of imitation as
mere automatic, mindless copying of others’ intellectual actions is rejected in favour of a stance of imitative activity as
intentional, goal-directed, transformative behaviour leading learners to new development levels” (de Guerrero &
Commander, 2013, p. 2). Imitation is a profoundly social process that learners use to connect with others and learn from
their actions and methods in meaningful contexts (Over, 2020). Learners will activate their mental processes through
meaningful imitation to construct their understanding of language. Language imitation, including language acquisition
and social interaction, is crucial in human development and learning (Damasceno, 2020).
Learners’ ZPD describes the gap between their ability to perform a task independently and their potential ability to do
it under guidance or collaboration. According to this concept, learning occurs in this zone (Lantolf & Poehner, 2008).
The texts to be copied by the participants in this study and the class interactions during the intervention process
represented the guidance and the meaningful contexts for learning. It is claimed here that copying texts after meaningful
interactions will help learners grasp grammatical points in unity and totality.
II. LITERATURE REVIEW
A. Grammar Learning Strategies
The present study perceives text copying as a deliberate action that learners consciously employ to control the
structures of a language better. This definition is adopted from the general definition of GLS as “deliberate thoughts and
actions that students consciously employed for learning and getting better control over the use of grammar structures”
(Cohen & Pinilla-Herrera, 2010, p. 64). Throughout the process of learning languages, grammar learning strategies hold
considerable importance. The study of language learning strategies, in general, has been extensive, but the study of
grammar learning strategies, in particular, has received relatively little attention (Pawlak, 2019).
There are, however, some recent studies attempting to address this issue. For example, Li (2022) conducted a
noteworthy review study highlighting how individuals’ differences, such as motivation and willingness to communicate,
influence how English as a foreign language (EFL) learners utilize grammar learning strategies. In a separate study,
ISSN 1799-2591
Theory and Practice in Language Studies, Vol. 14, No. 5, pp. 1421-1430, May 2024
DOI: https://doi.org/10.17507/tpls.1405.14
© 2024 ACADEMY PUBLICATION