Investigating the Factor of Water Consumption Regarding the Impact and Implementation
of Water Governance in Urban Areas
Iwan Juwana
1,2
, Sinan Vidi Lazuardi
2
, Herdis Herdiansyah
3*
1
Environmental Engineering Department, Institut Teknologi Nasional Bandung, Bandung 40123, Indonesia
2
Research Cluster of Interaction, Community Engagement, and Social Environment, School of Environmental Science,
Universitas Indonesia, DKI Jakarta 10430, Indonesia
3
School of Environmental Science, Universitas Indonesia, DKI Jakarta 10430, Indonesia
Corresponding Author Email: herdis@ui.ac.id
Copyright: ©2024 The authors. This article is published by IIETA and is licensed under the CC BY 4.0 license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
https://doi.org/10.18280/ijei.070107 ABSTRACT
Received: 8 January 2024
Revised: 15 February 2024
Accepted: 29 February 2024
Available online: 31 March 2024
Water governance becomes essential to meet societal needs despite water scarcity.
However, in Indonesia, disparities in water governance, especially in the area of water
quality perception, continue to exist. Therefore, this study investigates how water quality
perception is influenced by examining key factors such as satisfaction, trust, and socio-
economic status. This study was conducted in Jakarta by surveying through a
questionnaire. This study employed satisfaction, trust, and socio-economic status as
independent variables and the perception of water quality as a dependent variable. Also,
the chi-square test and ordinal logistic regression were employed to test the hypothesis and
the significance between independent and dependent variables. Chi-square tests reveal
correlations between trust, socioeconomic status, and perception of water quality.
However, regression analysis highlights socio-economic status and trust as the primary
influential factors. The study provides evidence of unequal access to water across different
socio-economic statuses and demonstrates how the need for government transparency and
trust in water institutions affects urban communities' perceptions of water quality.
Keywords:
inequalities, socio-economic status,
transparency, urban areas, water
governance, water management policies
1. INTRODUCTION
The preservation of water resources is paramount, serving
as a fundamental necessity for sustaining human life and
ensuring the well-being of future generations. This imperative
gains significance amid escalating populations and rapid
urbanization, intensifying water conservation issues [1].
Indonesia is a perfect example highlighting the criticality of
water conservation, with escalating concerns over water
sustainability. Data underscores these concerns, revealing a
significant decline in water quality—a plunge from 72.77 to
52.62 in the Water Quality Index 2019 [2]. The drop in the
water quality index in Indonesia has become a concern
because it has become one of the driving factors of water
scarcity, since deteriorating water quality could impede access
to clean water [3]. Several studies show that water scarcity has
negative impacts, such as public health risks due to potential
bacterial contamination. Studies, such as one undertaken by
Cronin et al. [4] in Jogjakarta, have revealed the relationship
between contaminated water—infected with E. coli and
Nitrate—and health risks, thereby impacting Sustainable
Development Goals (SDGs). Additionally, another study
indicates that water scarcity and pollution pose a high risk to
sectors heavily dependent on water, such as agriculture,
potentially causing substantial economic losses [5]. In
addition, while there is a need for responsible water
consumption to minimize water scarcity, polluted water
sources caused by improper waste management have
worsened the water scarcity in Indonesia [6]. Moreover,
mismanagement in various sectors-such as agriculture,
tourism, and manufacturing-exacerbates water scarcity
concerns, necessitating robust water management policies to
regulate sustainable water practices [6].
This study's significance is underscored by the wide-
ranging ramifications of water dynamics, extending their
influence across local and global contexts and addressing
multifaceted issues that demand urgent resolution. Health-
wise, contaminated water contributes to health problems and
even impacts stunting rates among children due to inadequate
access to safe drinking water and sanitation [7]. In addition to
health considerations, water scarcity exerts extensive
disruptive effects on economic-related issues [8], accounting
for a staggering global economic loss of approximately 2.7
trillion US dollars [9]. Industries reliant on water face
significant economic drawbacks due to water scarcity, as
highlighted by Roson and Damania's findings [10],
showcasing its adverse effects on economic activities and
global economic inequalities.
Efforts to address water-related concerns, encompassing
water security, equitable water allocation, and scarcity,
demand urgent solutions. Neto [11] asserts that water
governance efforts have been far below expectations,
emphasizing the need for an integrated framework involving
territorial and policy integration—an issue prevalent in
International Journal of Environmental Impacts
Vol. 7, No. 1, March, 2024, pp. 55-64
Journal homepage: http://iieta.org/journals/ijei
55