Controlling Vectors and Hosts of
Parasitic Diseases Using Fishes
A case history of schistosomiasis in Lake Malawi
Jay R. Stauffer Jr., Matthew E. Arnegard, Martin Cetron, James J. Sullivan, Lester A. Chitsulo,
George F. Turner, Soster Chiotha, and K. R. McKaye
C
urTent estimates of the glo-
bal prcvalcncc of parasitic
diseases range frorn 600 mil-
lion eases caused by protozoan and
rnetazoan parasitcs (Kolherg 1994)
to mOfe than 1 billion total eases
(Goodman 1994). Strategies for re-
ducing the transmission of these dis-
eases includc: immunizacton pro-
grams; reduction of parasite loads in
human populations via chemo-
therapy; modification of ctlltural
practices through public health edu-
eatlan, clean water, aod sanitation
projects; habitat modification (e.g.,
drainage of stagnant water bodiesl;
and biological and chemical vcctor
and host control (Warren aod
mo ud 1990, WHO 1990). Due
Jay R. Stauffer Jr. is a professor of
1chthyology and Matthew E. Arnegard
is a graduate at the School of
Forest Resollrces, Pennsdvania State
University Par'k, PA 1680l.
Martin Cetron is a medical epidemiolo-
gist and James J. Sullivan is a microhi-
ologist in the Division 01 Parasitic Dis-
eases at the Centers for Disease Control
and Prevention, 1600 Clifton Rd., At-
lanta, GA 10333. Lesrcr A. Chitsulo is
a programme manager of tlle AIDS
Control Programme in the N1inisrry of
Health and Population, Lilongv1te,
Mab,ki. Ccorgc F. Turner 1S Lccturcr in
Biodiversity and Ecology at rhe Univer-
sity of Sourhampron, Southampton, UK.
Chiorha is a university research
coordinator ar the University of Ma1a\\'i,
Zomha, 1\:1a1a\\'i. K. R. McKaye 1S a
professor at fhe Appalachian F.nviron-
mental Laboratory, University of 1\:1ary-
land Frosthnrg, \.·fD LI )"30. ©
1997 Amcric:1ll Institute of Biologieal
Sciences.
Januar)' 1997
Much of the published
research on the use of
predatory fishes to
regulate the population
densities of disease
vectors has not yielded
the predictive capabilities
that wise management
strategies require
largely to financial constraints (Kol-
berg 1994), however, many of these
approaches are inapplicable or un-
fcasible in underdevelopcd eountries,
where the vast ma;ority of the infec-
tions oecur.
Immunization is often not even
an option as acheck against the
spread of parasitic infections beeause
vaceines luve not beeil developed
foe man)' tropical Jiseases, especially
those caused by mctazoan parasites
(Warren and l\1ahmoud 1990). In
addition, cOst precludes chemo-
therapy as a control strategy
in endemie regions where rapid rein-
feetion rcquires repeated treatmem
over long periods of time (Slootweg
et al. 1994). Morcover, pharmaecu-
ticals have become obsolete where
parasites have developed
to these compounds (Kolherg 1994).
Access to clean water and ad-
cquate systems for thc disposal of
human wastes are important in the
prevention of waterborne parasitic
diseases because they aet to prevent
the completion' of parasite life cycles.
Development in this area, however,
has been poor. In 1990, only 10%,
13%, and 16% of rural populations
in eastern Mediterranean countries,
southeastcrn Asian eountries, and
Africa, respectively, had access to
suitable se wage disposal systems
(WHO 1.9.90); establishment of lle\V
facilities is just keeping pace with
population growth. Additional1y,
draining pond1'> that harbor para1'>ites
and their veetors may work against
the development needs (e.g., aqua-
culturc) in many countries (Chiotha
et al. 1991a).
Finally, there are serious limita-
tions to the use of pesticides for
vector control. Individual applica-
tions of a biocidal agent produce
sustained results on I)' whcn the vec-
tor are locally cxtirpated
(Conway 1976). Thus, mllitipie ap-
plications are for veetor
control, often at substantial (ost.
Environmental eontamination result-
ing from pesticide use is itself a risk
to public health and nontarget spe-
eies (e.g., natural predators of vec-
ton;), and resistance to pesticides
often dcve10ps in the vector popula-
tions (Ejiofor 1989, Kolberg 1994,
WHO 1992). Often the most cost-
effective strategies for controlling
and prevcming parasitic diseases in
developing countries may be hcaJth
and hygiene education and biologi-
cal veetor control.
Thc larrer of these two alterna-
tives is the focHs of this article-
41
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/bioscience/article-abstract/47/1/41/232481 by guest on 05 June 2020