JOURNAL OF AEROSOL MEDICINE
Volume 15, Number 4, 2002
© Mary Ann Liebert, Inc.
Pp. 379–385
In Vitro Effect of a Holding Chamber on the
Mouth–Throat Deposition of QVAR
®
(Hydrofluoroalkane-Beclomethasone Dipropionate)
MUHIB F. RAHMATALLA, Ph.D.,
1
PETER C. ZUBERBUHLER, M.D.,
2
CARLOS F. LANGE, Ph.D.,
1
and WARREN H. FINLAY, Ph.D.
1
ABSTRACT
Experimental work has been conducted on the effect of an add-on holding chamber (Aero-
chamber
®
) on the characteristics of deposition in a mouth–throat model using 100-mg hydro-
fluoroalkane-beclomethazone dipropionate (QVAR
®
) metered dose inhalers at inhalation
flow rates of 28.3, 60, and 90 L/min. A filter or cascade impactor downstream of the
mouth–throat collected aerosol not depositing. The results emphasize the important well doc-
umented effect of a valved holding chamber (VHC),
12
in reducing drug deposition in the
mouth–throat. This reduction is largest (24% of nominal dose) at the lowest flow rate tested,
becoming insignificant at 60 L/min. Total amount of drug delivered distal to the mouth–throat
increases with flow rate both with and without a holding chamber, increasing from 42% to
69% of the nominal dose without a VHC as the inspiratory flow rate increases from 28.3 to
90 L/min. The effect of the holding chamber on post mouth–throat delivery was small, reach-
ing significance only at the highest flow rate (90 L/min), where an increase by 8% of the nom-
inal dose was observed. No significant effect on MMAD of beclomethasone-dipropionate oc-
curred when the holding chamber was used. An argument based on the interaction between
induced turbulence and particle inertia is used to shed light on the above observations.
Key words: MDI, metered dose inhaler, spacer, aerosol, extrathoracic
379
INTRODUCTION
H
OLDING CHAMBERS are used with metered
dose inhalers (MDIs) to reduce extrathoracic
deposition and to alleviate patient coordination
issues associated with synchronizing inhalation
and actuation of the MDI. Holding chambers
achieve their effect by retaining the aerosol
sprayed from the MDI in a reservoir. This allows
the momentum of the particulate cloud to decay,
causes particle size to decrease due to propellant
evaporation, and decreases the need for inhala-
tion to begin simultaneously with release of
aerosol from the MDI. Many studies to evaluate
the effect of spacers have been performed in the
past. The objectives of previous studies were ei-
ther evaluating different drugs and formulations
with different spacers
1–5
or to concentrate on
other factors, such as the effect of multiple actu-
ations and increasing residence times of drug
The
1
Aerosol Research Laboratory of Alberta, Department of Mechanical Engineering, and
2
Cystic Fibrosis and Pe-
diatric Pulmonary Clinic, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.