Applied Engineering in Agriculture
Vol. 32(1): 63-68 © 2016 American Society of Agricultural and Biological Engineers ISSN 0883-8542 DOI 10.13031/aea.32.10883 63
TECHNICAL NOTE:
INEXPENSIVE IN-FIELD MANURE SOLIDS TESTER
R. A. Larson, J. Panuska, J. Sanford, C. Burnson
ABSTRACT. Manure losses from crop fields via surface and subsurface pathways following land application can lead to
eutrophication and habitat destruction in surface waters. High solids manure has less susceptibility to runoff and
leaching, which is particularly important in high risk fields with increased loss potential. Unfortunately, the determination
of manure solids content is typically conducted by laboratory analysis where results are provided after field application
has occurred. An inexpensive solids tester (less than $40 to construct) was developed out of readily available materials for
manure applicators to determine the solids content of liquid dairy manure in-field and in real time prior to application. As
manure samples are passed through the screen, solids are captured on the screen while more dilute manure passes
through. In order to evaluate the solids tester, 33 manure samples were collected from 6 separate dairies with a variety of
bedding types (3 farms used sand and 3 farms used recycled digested solids for bedding) and manure handling and
processing systems. Results indicated that the manure volume that is retained on the screen can be related to the solids
content of dairy manure from 3% to 9%. An equation was produced to relate manure solids to the volume retained on the
screen, TS=1.7953e
0.0046Vr
, with an r-squared value of 0.82. Manure samples with less than 3% solids were shown to pass
through the screen completely, therefore results were inaccurate for low TS content. The results did not vary significantly
for dairies which used sand bedding and those that used recycled manure solids. This quick in-field measurement of total
solids content allows for application to appropriate fields, thus reducing the risk of manure losses to nearby waterways.
Keywords. Dairy manure, Manure application, Manure characteristics, Total solids.
pproximately 1.3 million dairy cattle in the
United States (USDA-NASS, 2012) produce
over 8 billion gallons of dairy manure annually.
Nearly all dairy manure currently produced is
land applied to supply cropland with organic matter and the
necessary nutrients for plant growth. Prior to application,
manure is transported in and around the farmstead,
processed, and in many operations stored. The variability in
manure solids content can be considerable leading to
operational complications and difficult management
decisions throughout the entire manure management
system. Fresh dairy manure has been reported to contain
around 13% total solids (TS) when excreted (MWPS,
2004). However, changes in dairy herd management,
manure processing, and constituents in manure storages
have significantly impacted the solids content of dairy
manure, commonly reducing TS at many facilities. A
reduction in TS content is in part due to solid liquid
separation systems which allow producers to separate and
manage low and high solids content manures as well as the
addition of low TS wastewater (e.g., farmstead runoff and
milkhouse waste) to manure storages. In 2012, the TS
content of 19,085 liquid/slurry dairy manure samples
analyzed in Wisconsin laboratories ranged from <1% to
11.5% TS, with an average of 4.8% (samples over 11.5%
solids were considered solid manure samples) (Peters,
2013). These data indicate that many facilities are applying
manure with TS content lower than excreted values.
Manure TS content from one facility can vary significantly
making the design of manure handling systems and land
application more difficult (Safley et al., 1986). This also
makes handling and agitation of manure during application
variable from day to day or even between tanker loads.
More importantly, changes in manure content affect
application rates and management decisions concerning
application area/location.
When manure is applied to cropland correctly, it is a
sustainable practice that returns nutrients and organic
matter to soils maintaining fertility and health (Haynes and
Naidu, 1998). However, when low solids content manure is
applied to fields with a high runoff likelihood, it can
increase the movement of manure and/or associated
nutrients to surface waters resulting in eutrophication, algal
blooms, fish kills, and habitat destruction. This movement
and resulting environmental impact can be accentuated in
sensitive areas or locations which have increased
drainage/runoff such as croplands with significant slopes,
soils with low infiltration capacity, or soils with increased
Submitted for review in July 2014 as manuscript number NRES
10883; approved as a Technical Note for publication by the Natural
Resources & Environmental Systems Community of ASABE in
September 2015.
The authors are Rebecca A. Larson, Assistant Professor, John
Panuska, ASABE Member, Extension Specialist, Joseph Sanford,
ASABE Member, Graduate Student, and Christian Burnson, ASABE
Member, Water Resources Engineer, Montgomery Associates, Cottage
Grove, Wisconsin. Corresponding author: Rebecca A. Larson,
460 Henry Mall, Madison, WI, 53706; phone: 608-444-7662; e-mail:
ralarson2@wisc.edu.
A