An IEEE 802.21-based Approach to Integrate Unidirectional Wireless
Technologies into QoS-constrained Broadband Wireless Mesh Access Networks
Mathias Kretschmer
Fraunhofer FOKUS
Sankt Augustin, Germany
Gheorghita Ghinea
Brunel University
London, United Kingdom
Abstract
Wireless Mesh Networks (WMNs) research has ma-
tured in recent years and implementations are being tested
around the world. In a WMN, participating nodes are auto-
matically configured allowing them to communicate among
their peers via multiple hops when no direct physical con-
nectivity exists. This allows community networks such as
Freifunk[5] to provide affordable Internet access to their
communities by sharing a few gateway nodes. Increas-
ing demand for multi-media content poses a challenge for
the typical WMN routing protocols such as Optimised Link
State Routing (OLSR) which lack Quality of Service (QoS)
support. Although, numerous solutions have been proposed
to introduce QoS awareness, those WMNs fail to meet com-
mercial operator requirements in term of reliability and
QoS guarantees. In this paper we propose a novel IEEE
802.21-based approach seamlessly integrating broadcast
technologies such as Digital Video Broadcast (DVB) into
a heterogeneous multi-radio WMN architecture in order to
provide support for high-bandwidth multi-media services.
Keywords Heterogeneous technologies, QoS, IEEE
802.21, Wireless Mesh Network, MPLS, undirectional links
1 Introduction
The visibility of successful WMN deployments has
raised interest regarding a commercial exploitation of this
technology. Compared to traditional operator access net-
works, WMNs potentially offer easier deployment and flex-
ible self-configuration at lower costs. For a WMN-type ar-
chitecture to be considered as an alternative for an opera-
tor access network, it must meet similar requirements such
as guaranteed QoS and high availability. QoS support for
WMNs has received a lot of attention from the research
community [10][1][19], but has yet to show its applicability
in real world deployments.
Compared to the Freifunk-approach which relies on
cheap off-the-shelf hardware, a Carrier-grade Wireless
Mesh Access Network (CG-WMAN) may assume more re-
liable and higher performing multi-radio hardware yielding
more stable and potentially orthogonal links. Thus, CG-
WMANs can be compared to a typical operator access net-
work with two major limiting factors: the severe capacity
constraints due to scarce wireless spectrum resources and
temporarily varying link conditions. A modern operator
access network needs to support triple-play services (web,
video, voice) which emphases the need to support QoS
guarantees and efficient resource utilization in a capacity-
constrained network. Wireless cell resource utilization can
be optimized by using the most suitable technology for a
given payload. For example, the delivery of live multime-
dia content is facilitated by only one transmitter, hence the
overhead of Media Access Control (MAC) protocols can be
avoided. Unidirectional technologies such as Digital Video
Broadcast - Terrestrial (DVB-T) offer a very efficient dis-
tribution medium for 1-to-N traffic and usually span across
multiple mesh hops.
Typically, WMNs rely on the bi-directionality of links
and can therefore not utilize Unidirectional Links (UDLs).
For example, Ad hoc On-Demand Distance Vector Routing
Protocol (AODV)[15] black-lists UDLs since they break the
distance vector algorithm. What’s more, most Mobile Ad-
hoc Network (MANET) and WMN protocols can not dif-
ferentiate between a faulty 802.11 link and an inherently
unidirectional link provided by a unidirectional technology.
In this paper we propose an Institute of Electrical and Elec-
tronics Engineers (IEEE) 802.21-based approach to seam-
lessly integrate UDLs into a heterogeneous CG-WMANs
so that higher layer services can transparently utilize them
when beneficial for a given payload or receiver distribution.
This paper is structured as follows. In the next section
we discuss work related to our CG-WMAN architecture fo-
cusing on the support for UDLs. In the following section
we compare two approaches to seamlessly integrate UDLs
into the CG-WMAN and identify which protocols or com-
International Journal for Infonomics (IJI), Volume 3, Issue 2, June 2010
Copyright © 2010, Infonomics Society 259