Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Cities
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/cities
Market versus public provision of local goods: An analysis of amenity
capitalization within the Metropolitan Region of Santiago de Chile
Yasna Cortés
⁎
, Victor Iturra
Department of Economics, Universidad Católica del Norte, Antofagasta 0610, Chile
ARTICLE INFO
JEL classification:
H42
R23
Keywords:
Urban amenities
Hedonic models
Housing values
Local governments
ABSTRACT
The liberalization of the Chilean economy since 1974 has generated important modifications on its urban devel-
opment policies. However, little attention has been paid to estimate how urban amenities are capitalized in housing
prices under this new scenario. In this paper, we explore this relationship through a hedonic pricing model and 27
urban amenities for the Chilean main urban agglomeration, the Metropolitan Region of Santiago (MR). We recognize
that the capitalization of urban amenities into housing prices is spatially heterogeneous, therefore we study this
relationship by using the geographically weighted regression (GWR). The main results suggest that urban amenities
play an important role in determining housing prices with a significant spatial heterogeneity, where notably dif-
ferences between public and private local services are found. Particularly, private services such as schools, shopping
centers, healthcare centers or restaurants have positive capitalizations on housing prices. In contrast, public schools,
public hospitals and public kindergartens have negative valuations in housing prices, suggesting that living closer to
these services reduces housing values. Our results provide policy makers with valuable elements when designing
urban policies in terms of the importance of heterogeneous valuations of urban amenities across neighborhoods, how
to allocate resources more efficiently to foster the quality of life on new urban residents and the need of considering
the economic segregation triggered by heterogeneous preferences to amenities across space.
1. Introduction
Cities in Latin America have experimented an accelerated growth with
an average rate of expansion of about 20 m
2
per minute (Inostroza, 2017),
and > 80% of people live in cities in Latin American and the Caribbean
countries (UN-Habitat, 2013). However, this urbanization process has
triggered several problems that have not been adequately addressed by
urban planners, such as the lack of public services, crime, and poverty
coupled with a marked housing deficit. These urban issues can be partially
explained by the phenomena of suburbanization and counter urbanization
that have characterized the growth in Latin American cities, being the
latter a rather complex phenomenon in larger urban agglomerations such
as the capitals of Chile, Peru and Argentina, named Santiago, Lima and
Buenos Aires respectively (García-Ayllón, 2016).
From the analysis of the urban sprawl in Latin American cities,
scholars agree that this process is also characterized by an increasing
significance of informal development, which has mostly occurred at the
fringe of the main Latin American cities (Inostroza, 2017). For instance,
while the core of cities like Santiago and Brasilia are increasingly losing
importance, these cities are also becoming less dense with an increased
land occupied by new households (Inostroza, Baur, & Csaplovics, 2013).
In this context, the literature recognizes that the growth of cities in
Latin American is a phenomenon with its own characteristics, where the
informal development plays a central role (Inostroza, 2017), alongside
with numerous urban issues that seriously affect the quality of life of
their residents (Libertun de Duren, 2018; Valente & Berry, 2016).
Although cities in Latin American share several characteristics in
regard their urbanization process, there is still a lack of empirical evi-
dence derived from the study on specific city attributes -especially
public services-, and their association with the quality of life of urban
residents across the main urban areas in Latin America (Powell &
Sanguinetti, 2010). This issue deserves special attention in light on the
need to provide further elements for urban planners to carry out po-
licies aimed at providing a better quality of public goods to the
households located in Latin American megacities.
In this vein, the main objective of this paper is to provide new
empirical evidence on the assessment of a large set of amenities for the
Metropolitan Region of Santiago (MR), Chile, one of the main urban
agglomeration in Latin America. To achieve this objective, we perform
a hedonic analysis using a novel data set, that includes measures for
public and private services, to estimate how these services are capita-
lized into housing prices. The objective of this analysis is twofold. First,
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cities.2019.01.015
Received 10 July 2018; Received in revised form 13 December 2018; Accepted 10 January 2019
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: ycortes01@ucn.cl (Y. Cortés), viturra@ucn.cl (V. Iturra).
Cities 89 (2019) 92–104
0264-2751/ © 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
T