The true incidence of traumatic spinal cord injuries
See paper by Sabre et al. on page 768.
doi:10.1111/ene.12540
The incidence of traumatic spinal cord injuries (SCIs)
is usually based on the number of patients arriving at
hospital alive. The true incidence, however, should
include patients who died at the scene. Very few stud-
ies have managed to include all patients [1–5]. Sabre
et al. have collected data of every traumatic SCI in
Estonia during 2005–2007 [1]. By ascertaining the
numbers though medical records and autopsy reports
from every hospital in the country, they calculated the
true incidence of traumatic SCI for the period.
The results are astonishing. Sabre et al. found an
annual incidence rate of 93.9 and 43.8 per million pop-
ulation respectively when including and excluding pre-
hospital deaths [1]. Less prominent differences have
been found in Mississippi [2] and Alberta [3]. The inci-
dence rate in Mississippi was 77 and 59 SCI per million
population per year respectively when including and
excluding pre-hospital deaths [2]. In Alberta, Canada,
the overall annual incidence rate was 52.5 and
44.3 million per population per year respectively [3].
Fifty-three per cent died prior to hospitalization in
Estonia [1], compared with 37.7% in Minnesota, USA
[4], 16.0% in Portugal [5] and 15.8% in Alberta,
Canada [3].
There were striking differences between the victims
who died pre-hospital and the patients who were
alive upon arrival with regard to age, gender, level of
injury and aetiology. Persons who died at the scene
of the accident were 10 years younger than those
who died later [1]. Sixty-five per cent of all women
died before arrival at hospital, compared with 50.2%
of men [1]. No other publication has previously
reported this.
The highest mortality was amongst the patients
with multiple trauma, 86.1% [1]. These findings corre-
late with a Swedish study where the patients who died
before admission to hospital had a much higher injury
severity score compared with those who were alive
upon arrival [6]. High cervical injuries are the most
serious injuries and 67.8% of the patients with these
injuries died [1].
Motor vehicle accidents (MVAs) accounted for
53.2% of injuries, followed by falls 27.4% [1]. Only
25.0% of all victims of MVAs were alive upon arrival
at hospital [1]. As a result the main cause of traumatic
SCI in Estonia when including pre-hospital deaths is
MVAs and when excluding pre-hospital deaths falls
[1]. These findings are supported by the Swedish study
which found a higher percentage of pre-hospital
deaths due to MVAs than falls [6]. The majority of
injury-related deaths occurred either at the scene or
before arrival at hospital [6].
Traffic accidents were the leading cause of death
amongst people aged 15–64 years in Estonia in the
period 2000–2002, based on post-mortem reports,
and 78.3% of the victims were men [7]. Fifty-eight
per cent of the victims were car occupants and 31%
were pedestrians [7]. Alcohol was a major contribut-
ing factor in these accidents, and the percentage of
alcohol-related deaths was highest amongst pedestri-
ans [7]. In the present study 55.2% of the population
and 46.8% of those who died had consumed alcohol
prior to the injury [1]. Studies have shown that both
male gender and age are associated with increased
mortality rates amongst injured persons [8]. The high
mortality among women as found by Sabra et al. [1]
is interesting and calls for further studies.
Collecting true epidemiological data on trauma is a
difficult exercise but has important implications with
regard to the development of prevention strategies,
locally, regionally and nationally. The meticulous
work that Sabre et al. have done proves the necessity
of including pre-hospital deaths in future epidemiolog-
ical studies of traumatic SCI.
E. M. Hagen
a,b,c
a
Department of Neurology, Spinal Cord Injury Centre of Western
Denmark, Viborg Regional Hospital, Viborg, Denmark;
b
Institute
of Clinical Medicine, University of Bergen, Bergen, Norway; and
c
Institute of Clinical Medicine, Aarhus University, Aarhus,
Denmark
(e-mail: ellen.merete.hagen@helse-bergen.no)
References
1. Sabre L, Remmer S, Adams A, et al. Impact of fatal
cases on the epidemiology of traumatic spinal cord injury
in Estonia. Eur J Neurol 2015; 22: 768–772.
2. Surkin J, Gilbert BJ, Harkey HL III, Sniezek J, Currier
M. Spinal cord injury in Mississippi. Findings and evalu-
ation, 1992 1994. Spine 2000; 25: 716–721.
© 2014 EAN 743
EDITORIAL
EUROPEANJOURNALOFNEUROLOGY