Exercise Training and Depression in ESRD: A Review
Georgia I. Mitrou,*
1
Stefania S. Grigoriou,*†
1
Evi Konstantopoulou,* Paraskevi
Theofilou,†‡ Christoforos D. Giannaki,§ Ioannis Stefanidis,¶ Christina Karatzaferi,*† and
Giorgos K. Sakkas*†¶
*Department of PE and Sport Science, University of Thessaly, Trikala, Greece, †Department of Kinesiology,
Centre for Research and Technology Hellas, Greece, ‡Department of Psychology, Panteion University,
Athens, Greece, §Department of Life & Health Sciences, University of Nicosia, Cyprus, and ¶School of
Health Science, Department of Medicine, University of Thessaly, Larissa, Greece
ABSTRACT
Depression, a mental disorder with a high personal, socie-
tal, and economic impact, affects at least 20–30% of
patients receiving hemodialysis therapy. It is associated
with a high mortality rate, low adherence to medication,
and a low perceived quality of life. Exercise training is a
promising nonpharmacological intervention that can be
safely applied to these patients. Beyond the well-publi-
cized physiological benefits of exercise training, a number
of studies have focused on the effects of exercise training
on mental factors and quality of life parameters including
its less appreciated effects on depression symptoms. This
evidence-based review article reviews and discusses the
effects of exercise training on depression in end-stage
renal disease patients.
Patients receiving hemodialysis (HD) therapy
have a low quality of life (QoL), often accompanied
by significant emotional distress characterized by
symptoms of depression and anxiety (1). Depression
is the most common mental disorder in HD patients
(2) and is second only to hypertension in frequency
as a comorbid diagnosis (3,4). In the last decade,
nephrologists have begun to look more systemati-
cally for signs of depression as its recognition as an
important factor influencing a patient’s overall
health status and survival (5). It may also be one of
the major contributors to the low medication adher-
ence observed in dialysis patients, which by itself is
associated with increased mortality risk (5).
There is evidence that physical activity and exer-
cise training improve the general health of patients
with end-stage renal disease (ESRD) reducing the
burden of common associated comorbidities (6–8)
including hypertension, heart diseases, musculoskel-
etal problems, and diabetes mellitus (9). There is
also strong evidence suggesting that systematic exer-
cise training and high physical activity levels are
effective and safe nonpharmacological treatments,
which improve both mental and physiological
aspects of health with direct effects on patients’
QoL and mortality (10).
Most studies of this subject have assessed depres-
sion score as a “side parameter” or as an aspect of
the patients’ QoL score (11). In addition, there are
investigations assessing the effectiveness of exercise
training compared with other nonpharmacological
approaches for the improvement of the mental
health (MH) of HD patients or more specifically,
depression.
The aim of this review is to describe and cover in
critical fashion the data that do exist on the effect
of exercise training programs on depressive symp-
toms encountered in HD patients and assess
whether exercise is a useful nonpharmacological
tool for improving patients’ MH.
Prevalence and Symptoms of Depression in
HD Patients
Depression affects approximately 20–30% of
ESRD patients (12–15); some studies have reported
even higher percentages (16). Many factors contrib-
ute to the high prevalence of this disorder in the
HD population including an amalgam of mental,
physical, and social factors that frequently coexist
and result in high levels of emotional distress.
Depression is also linked to the dialysis treatment
itself, which requires from patients long periods
attached to the dialysis machine, a fact that clearly
Address correspondence to: Giorgos K. Sakkas PhD,
Department of Kinesiology, Institute of Research and
Technology Thessaly, Centre for Research and Technol-
ogy Hellas (CERTH), Karies, Trikala, Thessaly, GR42100,
Greece, Tel.: +30-2431-500-911. Fax: +30-2413-501667, or
e-mail: gsakkas@med.uth.gr.
1
Equal first authors.
Seminars in Dialysis—Vol 26, No 5 (September–October)
2013 pp. 604–613
DOI: 10.1111/sdi.12112
© 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
604