SPINE Volume 25, Number 22, pp 2916 –2924
©2000, Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Inc.
Multifidus Spasms Elicited by Prolonged
Lumbar Flexion
Mathew Williams, BSc, Moshe Solomonow, PhD, MD (Hon),
Bing He Zhou, EE, Richard V. Baratta, PhD, and Mitchel Harris, MD
Study Design. The electromyogram of the L1–L7 mul-
tifidus muscles of the in vivo cat were recorded while
applying a prolonged steady displacement to the lumbar
spine through the L4 –L5 supraspinous ligament, simulat-
ing a moderate anterior flexion.
Objective. To demonstrate that tension-relaxation and
laxity of the viscoelastic structures (ligaments, discs, and
capsules) induced by prolonged static flexion of the spine
results in loss of reflexive muscular stabilizing activity
and in muscular disorders that may lead to or are asso-
ciated with low back pain.
Summary of Background. Epidemiologic data show
that prolonged loading of the spine, such as in some
occupational activities, can cause low back pain and mus-
cle spasms. Direct experimental evidence linking pro-
longed loading to a decrease in spinal stability, low back
pain, and muscle spasms was not found. It was hypoth-
esized, however, that mechanoreceptors in the viscoelas-
tic structures, when strained, reflexively activate the mul-
tifidus muscles to maintain intervertebral stability; that
the reflexive muscular activity decreases with stress-re-
laxation and laxity in the viscoelastic structures; and that
when severe strain and possible damage of the viscoelas-
tic structures occurs with time, nociceptive receptors elicit
spasms in the musculature and possible pain.
Methods. The lumbar spine of seven in vivo cat prep-
arations was displaced through the L4 –L5 supraspinous
ligament into moderate flexion that was steadily main-
tained for 50 minutes while intramuscular electromyo-
grams were recorded from each of the multifidus muscles
of L1–L2 through L6 –L7. Load and electromyogram were
continuously monitored and recorded. Five additional
preparations were used as controls, in which dissection
and recordings were identical, but the lumbar flexion was
excluded.
Results. Prolonged flexion of the lumbar spine re-
sulted in initial reflexive electromyogram from the multi-
fidus muscles that decreased to approximately 5% of its
initial value as tension-relaxation began in the viscoelas-
tic structures within the first 3 minutes, after which, ran-
dom and unpredictable electromyogram discharges (i.e.,
spasms) of high amplitude were recorded from different
levels. In some preparations the spasms were present in
L1–L4, and in others in all the levels. In other preparations
the spasms were recorded only at L5 and L6. The onset of
the spasms was also unpredictable, because they were
initiated in some cases within 2–3 minutes after the spine
was loaded. In other cases, the spasms were observed
anytime during the test period and up to 20 minutes after
the load was removed. Spasms were also observed in the
spinalis and longissimus muscles.
Conclusions. Prolonged flexion of the lumbar spine
results in tension-relaxation and laxity of its viscoelastic
structures, loss of reflexive muscular activity within 3
minutes and electromyogram spasms in the multifidus
and other posterior muscles. [Key words: electromyo-
gram, ligament, low back pain, lumbar, multifidus,
spasms spine] Spine 2000;25:2916 –2924
It is well established that the musculature associated with
the lumbar spine is the primary structure responsible for
its stability, whereas the passive viscoelastic structures
(ligaments, discs, and capsules) function as secondary
stabilizers.
5,7,9,16,21
The musculature and the viscoelastic
tissues of the spine, however, function synergistically, so
that the desired movement is accomplished while the sta-
bility of the spine is preserved.
21
Recent evidence has
shown that a spinal reflex arc exists from mechanorecep-
tors in the ligaments, discs, and facet capsules to the lumbar
multifidus and longissimus muscles in humans
28
and in fe-
line
28,29
and porcine
13,14
models. Strain of the lumbar vis-
coelastic structures was shown to excite the mechanore-
ceptors within and reflexively contract the multifidus
muscles of the distracted motion segment. Partial activa-
tion of the multifidus muscles of two to three levels above
and below was also observed. Such muscular forces pro-
vide sufficient stiffness to prevent excessive displacement
of several vertebrae relative to each other and the conse-
quent possible injury.
28
More recently, Solomonow et al
27
and Gedalia et al
6
have shown that tension-relaxation and the associated
laxity induced in the viscoelastic structures due to cyclic
loading of the lumbar spine desensitize the mechanore-
ceptors within. The resultant biexponential decrease of
reflexive muscular activity of the multifidus leaves the
spine without muscular protection against excessive in-
tervertebral displacement.
Adams et al
1
showed that creep in the viscoelastic
structures was also present when the spine was subjected
to steady load over time, as would be expected during
prolonged anterior flexion while gardening or bricklay-
ing, for example. They also observed that in human sub-
jects, the musculature did not compensate for the lost
stiffness (e.g., laxity) in the spine. The exact correlation
between the load applied to the spine, the laxity induced,
From the Bioengineering Laboratory, Department of Orthopaedic Sur-
gery, Louisiana State University Medical Center, New Orleans, Loui-
siana.
This work was supported by Grant R01-0H-4709-01 from NIOSH.
MW was a research medical student supported by the Department of
Orthopaedic Surgery.
Acknowledgment date: August 3, 1999.
Acceptance date: January 13, 2000.
Device status category: 1.
Conflict of interest category: 14.
2916