2024 © Uva Clinical Anaesthesia and Intensive Care ISSN 2827-7198 / Medical Education / Portfolio-based learning
2024 © Uva Clinical Anaesthesia and Intensive Care ISSN 2827-7198 / Medical Education / Portfolio-based learning
2024 © Uva Clinical Anaesthesia and Intensive Care ISSN 2827-7198 / Medical Education / Portfolio-based learning
1
The Role of Portfolios in Medical Professional
Indunil Karunarathna
1
, U Vidanagama
1
, C Fernando
1
, U Ekanayake
1
, T Hapuarachchi
1
, P Gunasena
1
, P Aluthge
1
, N
Perera
1
, S Gunathilake
1
, Kapila De Alvis
1
, K Gunawardana
1
, S Rajapaksha
1
, A Warnakulasooriya
1
, P Athulgama
1
,
Sanjeewa Dius
1
, R Ranwala
1
, Sau Bandara
1
, Sanjaya Godage
1
, PN Rodrigo
1
, Asoka Jayawardana
1
,
1. Ministry of Health / Teaching Hospital Badulla / University of Colombo. 2024 © Uva Clinical Anaesthesia and Intensive Care ISSN 2827-7198 / Medical Education
/ Portfolio-based learning
Abstract: Portfolio-based learning has become an integral tool in the professional development of doctors, supporting
reflective practices, self-directed learning, and career-long development. However, its implementation is often met
with practical and ideological challenges, including time constraints, structural clarity, and technological expectations.
This article explores the benefits of portfolios, their use across different stages of medical training, and the barriers to
their effective adoption. It highlights the potential of e-portfolios to overcome practical limitations while underscoring
the importance of reflection as a cornerstone of professional growth. Practical solutions and strategies are discussed
to address the challenges and enhance portfolio utility in medical education.
Keywords: Portfolio-based learning, Medical education, Professional development, Reflective practice, E-portfolios,
Medical training, Self-directed learning
Key Points
Role of Portfolios in Medical Education: Portfolios
support self-directed learning, reflective practices, and
career progression by documenting achievements,
assessments, and professional growth.
Challenges in Adoption: Issues such as time constraints,
unclear structure, inadequate support, and user attitudes
limit the effective use of portfolios.
E-Portfolios as a Solution: Technological innovations
offer practical benefits, such as ease of access and
enhanced functionality, but require significant investment
and user-centered design.
Reflection as a Central Element: Reflection in portfolios
fosters insights into professional strengths and areas for
improvement, aligning with modern educational and
societal expectations.
Practical Recommendations: Clear guidance,
mentorship training, streamlined processes, and robust e-
portfolio systems are essential for overcoming barriers
and enhancing the value of portfolios.
Introduction:
Portfolio-based learning is a relatively recent innovation
in medical education, marking a significant departure
from traditional pedagogical approaches long associated
with the training of doctors. Traditionally, medical
education has emphasized didactic teaching, rote
memorization, and standardized assessments. In contrast,
portfolio-based learning prioritizes reflective practice,
personalized learning experiences, and continuous
documentation of progress. Despite its novelty, the
adoption of portfolios has grown rapidly, largely in
response to evolving trends and challenges in medical
education. These include the demand for increased
accountability and the professionalization of medical
trainers.
Changes Driving Portfolio-Based Learning
To fully appreciate the rise of portfolio-based learning, it
is important to understand the contextual factors
underpinning its adoption. Two key trends have been
particularly influential:
1. Increasing Levels of Accountability
Accountability has always been a cornerstone of medical
practice, rooted in the ethical and professional principles
outlined in the Hippocratic Oath. However, recent decades
have seen a heightened emphasis on regulatory oversight
and quality assurance in medical education. This trend
stems from a broader societal demand for transparency,
safety, and public trust in healthcare.
Historical Milestones in Accountability:
In 1993, the Calman Report, Hospital Doctors: Training
for the Future, initiated a transformation of postgraduate
medical training by introducing structured training