Microbiology
Acta Spartae Vol. 2 No. 1 2016
Pages 14–15
Comparison of Antibiotic Susceptibility of Bacterial
Communities on Cell Phones Belonging to Health Care
Workers and Non-Health Care Workers
Matt Guillemette, Zachary Rivera, and Eric Freundt
1
Department of Biology, University of Tampa, Tampa, FL 33606,
1
Faculty Advisor
ABSTRACT
The frequent use of cell phones inside of health care facilities
produces a risk of contamination of the phones with potentially
pathogenic bacteria. The elevated use of antibiotics within these
health care facilities may also contribute to heightened levels of
antibiotic resistant strains on these devices. To assess this, bacterial
samples were collected from health care workers’ and non-health
care workers’ cell phones. The bacterial isolates were assessed
for antibiotic resistance via the Kirby-Bauer method. Eleven out of
nineteen of the bacterial isolates from the health care workers cell
phones displayed resistance to at least one antibiotic. According to
our study, the lower amount of resistance of the bacteria isolated
from the health care worker samples compared to the non-health
care worker samples leads us to conclude that there is not a higher
prevalence of antibiotic resistant bacteria on health care workers’
phones.
1 INTRODUCTION
Bacterial cells are found on every surface from cell phones to the
kitchen counter. The average bacterial cell is 1–4 micrometers in
diameter. This means that about one million bacterial cells will take
up the same amount of area as one grain of sand. If one million
bacterial cells can fit in the same area as a grain of sand then the
amount of bacteria that can fit on a cell phone surface would be
astronomical.
Sterile bacterial swabs of cell phones have been conducted
and several colonies of bacteria have been isolated (Akinyemi
et al., 2009). Furthermore, computer keyboards were swabbed
for bacterial growth and produced results similar to those of cell
phones (Sergio et al., 2000). Individuals are in contact with these
two surfaces multiple times every day which could be leading to
increased rates of bacterial infection.
Health care workers should be extremely careful when using
their cell phones in the hospital because of their increased level of
exposure to drug-resistant strains of bacteria. A study of 200 health
care workers demonstrated that 94.5% of their cell phones exhibited
evidence of bacterial contamination (Ulger et al., 2009) There is
evidence that cell phones contain the same bacterial contamination
that peoples hands do thus acting has successful fomites. Cell
phones have been proven to be effective in transporting bacteria,
which can be how these bacterial infections are spreading (Noskin
et al., 1995).
Knowing that cell phones are effective mechanisms for bacteria
transport, effective methods for cell phone disinfection should
be studied. Previous work has shown that bacteria are able to
survive on fingertips for at least 60 minutes (Pal et al., 2015),
it is rational to believe that there is bacterial contamination all
over cell phones. This was the focus of investigation in the
following experiment. In this study, we isolated and cultured
several species of bacteria from cell phones used in every day
environments and compared the results to cell phones that are
used within the healthcare environment. Upon determining the
differences in colony morphologies, we tested the bacteria for
resistance against two antibiotics. The two antibiotics used were
erythromycin and ampicillin. Erythromycin is an antibiotic that
affects gram-positive strains of bacteria much more efficiently than
gram-negative strains. It was shown that the uptake of erythromycin
by gram-positive species was 100 times greater than that of gram-
negative species (Mao & Putterman, 1968). There was a close
relationship between the accumulation of erythromycin and the
ability to inhibit the growth of gram-positive bacteria. Ampicillin
is considered to be a beta-lactam antibiotic and has been proven
to treat both gram-positive and gram-negative species of bacteria.
The ability for beta-lactam drugs to inhibit the growth of bacterial
species is dependent upon binding to specific targets located in the
cytoplasmic membrane of the bacteria (Knowles, 1985). Binding
of beta-lactam drugs to target proteins results in the inability for
bacteria to synthesize a peptidoglycan cell wall, ultimately causing
cell rupture. More specifically, the acylation of a serine hydroxyl
group at the active site is what results in inactivation of the cell-wall
synthesizing protein (Knowles, 1985).
Antibiotic resistance is becoming an increasingly common feature
of bacterial species. There are several ways that they can become
resistant. First, the target enzymes may become less susceptible to
acylation, which inhibits inactivation of the protein. Another way
is through changes in the outer membrane permeability resulting
in the inability for the drug to penetrate the cell wall and reach
the target protein in the cytoplasm. However, the most common
method of resistance is specific toward beta-lactam antibiotics. The
appearance of the enzyme beta-lactamase results in destruction
of the antibiotic before it can reach the target protein within the
bacterial cell (Malouin & Bryan, 1986) In this study, we assessed
whether or not the cellphones of healthcare professionals are more
susceptible to becoming contaminated with drug-resistant bacteria
than phones in community settings.
2 MATERIALS AND METHODS
Bacterial samples were collected from cell phones that were
frequently used inside of a long term health care facility (labeled
Hospital). The samples were collected from 8 volunteers who
perform various tasks such as cleaning and observing patient-
doctor interactions. Also samples from various phones that are
14 © 2016 Matt Guillemette, Zachary Rivera, and Eric Freundt, published with permission