Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Applied Acoustics
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/apacoust
Technical note
HVAC noise control using natural materials to improve vehicle interior
sound quality
Sneha Singh
⁎
, A.R. Mohanty
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur, Kharagpur 721302, West Bengal, India
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Noise control
Sound quality
Jute felt
Natural materials
Sound absorption
HVAC
ABSTRACT
Heating, Ventilation and Air Conditioning (HVAC) unit is a major noise source in a vehicle’s interior space.
Reducing this noise will improve the sound quality of the vehicle’s interior space and enhance passengers’
experience. However, current noise control techniques are high-cost and hazardous to environment. Therefore,
this paper studies the first ever usage of low-cost, biodegradable natural materials for vehicle’s HVAC noise
control. Jute felt and waste cotton were found to have higher sound absorption coefficients than other common
sound absorbing natural materials, and were chosen as sound absorbers for noise control treatment of a pro-
totype HVAC unit. Noise sources in the unit were identified and ranked, and the treatment was applied to these.
The treatment significantly reduced the noise level (by 4 dBA) and loudness level (by 7 sones) due to the unit at
the reference passenger’s ear location, with negligible cost and weight. Sound quality evaluation by 24 parti-
cipants showed that the treatment significantly reduced the annoyance of the vehicle interior soundscape
comprising the HVAC noise. Thus, jute felt and waste cotton are low-cost, light-weight, biodegradable and
recyclable natural materials with high potential for HVAC noise control.
1. Introduction
Sound quality of a vehicle interior space is an important aspect of a
vehicle and demands special NVH (Noise, Vibration and Harshness)
attention. Reducing noise inside a vehicle improves the sound quality of
the vehicle interior space, which in turn leads to a higher passenger
comfort, better driving experience, and lesser driver distraction.
Moreover, reducing noise and improving vehicle interior sound quality
enhances a customer’s perception of the vehicle brand; thereby the
vehicle attracts more customers and gets a competitive advantage in the
market [1,2].
Research and development over the last two decades have led to
quieter and better sounding engines. As a result, secondary sound
sources located within a vehicle cabin such as heating, ventilation and
air-conditioning (HVAC) system, entertainment systems, and audio
driver assist systems have become more perceptible to passengers [3].
Among the secondary sources, the HVAC system is the most dominant
noise source in a vehicle’s interior space as it operates throughout as
long as the vehicle is running. Additionally, the HVAC and blower fan
noise reaches the interior space without any sound isolation and can
strongly impact passengers’ comfort. In the hot climate of a tropical
country like India, a vehicle’s HVAC system operates continuously at
higher blower speeds and is one of the most important interior noise
sources. Therefore, HVAC noise control is needed to improve the sound
quality of the vehicle interior space, and it is gaining growing attention
from researchers and manufacturers [3–8].
1.1. Conventional methods for HVAC noise control and sound quality
enhancement
The major noise source in the HVAC unit is the aerodynamic blower
noise [9–12]. Therefore, the conventional strategy for reducing HVAC
noise includes design changes to the blower and its blades [9,10,13,14].
However, the unit examined in this paper was already designed and
produced by the manufacturer for optimum performance; hence only
noise control strategies at post-production stage are discussed in this
paper. Existing post-production noise control techniques include active
noise control [4,11,15], and passive noise control using synthetic sound
absorbing materials such as micro-perforates [5,6], fiberglass, glass
wool and polypropylene [16]. These approaches achieve up to 6–10 dB
noise reduction. However, active noise control approaches involve
costly equipment, work well only in low frequencies, and are effective
only in specific zones of the vehicle interior space. Passive noise control
approaches work best at frequencies above ≈500 Hz, and they apply
noise reduction throughout the interior space. However, the synthetic
sound proofing materials are costly as their manufacturing requires
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apacoust.2018.05.013
Received 13 February 2018; Received in revised form 7 May 2018; Accepted 9 May 2018
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: snehasingh.iitkgp@gmail.com (S. Singh).
Applied Acoustics 140 (2018) 100–109
0003-682X/ © 2018 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
T