ISSN 1813-1166. NAU Proceedings. 2008. №2
© Oleksandr I. Zaporozhets, Oleg O. Kartyshev, Gregory G. Golembievskiy, 2008
52
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
UDC 626.517
Oleksandr I. Zaporozhets, D. E. Prof.
Oleg O. Kartyshev, Candidate of Engineering (Russia)
Gregory G. Golembievskiy, assoc. Prof.
ACCURACY AND UNCERTAINTY OF AIRCRAFT NOISE MODELLING
Various models for predicting aircraft noise around airports are described. Improved acoustic models of aircraft are
formed by summing models for the noise sources peculiar to each of the aircraft types. Their accuracy and uncertainty are
assessed by means of comparison with flight trials measurements.
Описано різні моделі для прогнозу авіаційного шуму навколо аеропортів. Поліпшені акустичні моделі літаків
створено за допомогою складання моделей для окремих джерел шуму, особливих для кожного з типів літаків.
Їх точність і достовірність оцінено порівнянням з вимірюваннями, виконаними під час випробувальних польотів.
Introduction
The ability to assess and predict noise exposure
accurately is an increasingly important factor in the
design and implementation of any airport
improvements [1]. Possible methods for modelling
noise radiation, propagation and attenuation, include
both analytical and semi-empirical results.
The current tendency is towards less empirical and
more analytical and numerical techniques. It should
he noted that ICAO is carrying out analyses of
existing models and methods for assessing the
acoustical characteristics of the various sources
associated with aircraft noise events and is making
proposals for their use [2; 3].
Two approaches to analysis of aircraft noise
phenomena have been defined and implemented in
computer programs. The first approach is based on
l/3-octave band spectra noise analysis of any type of
aircraft in any mode of flight or during maintenance
activities in the vicinity of an airport. It provides
estimation of any type of aircraft noise criteria by
means of set of noise spectra varied during the
particular noise event or for any kind of noise
exposure. The approach is implemented in a model
and appropriate software NoBel. The second
approach is based on the concept of "noise radius"
and provides calculations of aircraft noise exposure
units around the airports or at any noise monitoring
point. The basic "noise radius"- relationships may be
obtained from experimental data as well as by
calculation (for example, by using the NoBel
program). The task of deriving an acoustic model for
each type of the aircraft under consideration has been
proposed and solved in a manner that reconciles
experimental data with calculation.
Thus, the aircraft noise models, used in BELTRA
solutions, are of sufficient reliability and accuracy.
The second modelling approach has been utilized in
software IsoBell'a. Here, the basic acoustic models
for aircraft of any type will be examined on its
accuracy and uncertainty.
The acoustic model of an aircraft
An aircraft is represented by a set of noise matrices,
each dependent on flight mode and consisting of
sound pressure level (SPL) spectra (in a l/3-oclave
band form) for a defined number of directions of
sound propagation from the acoustic source. In some
cases the noise matrices are obtained experimentally,
in others they are obtained by means of calculations
based on the models for the particular acoustic
sources [4-10] of interest for the aircraft under
consideration. It is impossible to define the
characteristics of all phenomena by means of
analytical and semiempirical models only. The most
common phenomena determining or influencing the
accuracy of noise matrices are the engine installation
effects and noise abatement treatments. Both
experiments and calculations have some
disadvantages and the derivation has been formulated
to overcome them [1].
The sound pressure level spectrum {SPL
jk
) of aircraft
noise of any type in spectral bands N
j
, j=1,N
j
, and in
some k-th direction of sound propagation, where k =
1, N
k
, with reference to previous considerations, can
be defined by:
jk jkp jk
SPL SPL SPL , (1)
where
SPL
jkp
is the predicted value of SPL
jk
resulting from a
sum of particular models SPL
jki
for characteristic (or
dominant) noise sources, i = 1,..,N
s
;