328
ASAIO Journal 2013
Legionella-associated respiratory failure has a high mortality,
despite modern ventilation modalities. Extracorporeal mem-
brane oxygenation (ECMO) is used to achieve gas exchange
independent of pulmonary function in patients with severe
respiratory failure. This was a retrospective review of the man-
agement and outcome of patients with Legionella-associated
respiratory failure treated with ECMO support in a large ECMO
center over the past 10 years. A retrospective review of patients
with confirmed Legionella-associated severe respiratory fail-
ure managed with ECMO support at a single center. Between
2000 and 2010, 19 patients with severe respiratory failure
caused by Legionella were managed with ECMO after failure to
respond to conventional intensive care management. Median
PaO
2
/FiO
2
ratio was 66 and median pCO
2
was 60 torr. Sixteen
patients (84%) survived to hospital discharge. Extracorporeal
membrane oxygenation should be considered in patients with
Legionella-associated respiratory failure, who have failed con-
ventional ventilation. ASAIO Journal 2013;59:328–330.
Key Words: extracorporeal membrane oxygenation, Legion-
naire’s disease, severe respiratory failure, Legionella
Acute respiratory failure secondary to Legionella carries a
significant morbidity and mortality, which has varied little in
England and Wales since 1980,
1
despite the introduction of
urine antigen testing and improved antimicrobial therapy dur-
ing this period.
2,3
Mortality reported by the Health Protection
Agency for England and Wales in 2009 was 12.5% compared
with 13% in 1980. Some authors have reported the mortality
for patients with Legionnaire’s disease requiring intensive care
management as 30%
4
and 33%.
5
Lung protective ventilation is the standard for patients with
acute respiratory failure requiring mechanical ventilation.
High-frequency oscillatory ventilation (HFOV) and prone posi-
tioning are optional adjunctive therapies. Despite these man-
agement strategies, a small subset of patients exists in whom
adequate oxygenation or carbon dioxide removal cannot be
achieved. Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) has
been shown to improve outcome for adults who have failed
conventional management.
6,7
By routing the patient’s blood
through an extracorporeal circuit with an incorporated oxy-
genator, gas exchange is not solely dependent on the lungs,
permitting lung protective ventilation.
The Heartlink ECMO Centre at Leicester has been provid-
ing ECMO support since 1989. In 1999, a report from this
center on confirmed or probable Legionella pneumonia man-
aged with ECMO support showed a survival of 53.8%.
8
The
conduct of ECMO, mode of cannulation, and type of circuit
have since evolved.
We hereby review the management and outcome of patients
with Legionella pneumonia managed with ECMO support at
the same ECMO center over the past 10 years.
Methods
Study Design, Setting, and Participants
A retrospective review at a single ECMO center of patients with
confirmed Legionella-associated acute respiratory failure man-
aged with ECMO support. Study period ranged from October
2000 to September 2010. Inclusion criteria were age >18 years,
primary diagnosis of confirmed Legionella, and management with
ECMO support. Patients who were managed conventionally at the
Heartlink ECMO Centre were excluded from this report.
Data Sources
Patients were identified from the locally held ECMO database.
Search fields included Legionella as the primary diagnosis both
at referral to ECMO and at discharge from ECMO. Information
was obtained from the case notes, referral sheets, extracorporeal
life support organization forms, and discharge summaries of the
patients identified. The case notes of three patients had been
destroyed, but adequate information could be obtained on the
patients from the other sources to allow inclusion in this review.
Variables
To define clinical status before ECMO, we documented
demographics (age, weight, and sex), date of intubation, use
Case Series
Extracorporeal Membrane Oxygenation and Severe Acute
Respiratory Distress Secondary to Legionella:
10 Year Experience
MORONKE A. NOAH, GEETHANJALI RAMACHANDRA, MARGARET M. HICKEY, DAVID R. JENKINS, CHRIS J. HARVEY,
CLAIRE A. WESTROPE, RICHARD K. FIRMIN, AND GILES J. PEEK
Copyright © 2013 by the American Society for Artificial Internal
Organs
DOI: 10.1097/MAT.0b013e31829119c6
From the Heartlink ECMO Centre, University Hospitals of Leicester
NHS Trust, Leicester, UK.
Submitted for consideration June 2012; accepted for publication in
revised form February 2013.
Disclosure: The authors have no conflicts of interest to report.
Reprint Requests: Moronke A. Noah, Department of Anaesthetics,
Leicester Royal Infirmary, University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust,
Infirmary Square, Leicester LE1 5WW, UK. Email: abinoah@doctors.
org.uk.