In the Storm’s Eye: How Race,
Experience, and Exposure Shape
Arizona Teachers’ Attitudes
Toward School Choice
FREDERICK HESS
American Enterprise Institute
ROBERT MARANTO
Villanova University
SCOTT MILLIMAN
James Madison University
KATHLEEN GRAMMATICO FERRAIOLO
University of Virginia
Amidst the growing research on choice-based school reform, little attention has been
paid to examining how teachers view school choice or what factors shape their
attitudes. Teachers can impact the success of choice experiments through their will-
ingness to launch and staff schools of choice, share information with teachers at those
schools, and support change in their unions and communities. Examining Arizona,
the state with the nation’s most developed system of choice, we explore how personal
traits, including race, tenure, partisanship, and familiarity with charter schooling,
influence teachers’ attitudes toward charter schools and school vouchers. In addition,
we examine how other school- or district-level variables, including culture and char-
ter penetration, inform teachers’ views. Finally, to assess the effect of experience with
school choice, we examine the factors that shape charter schoolteachers’ views about
choice. Using a 1998 survey, we find that White, experienced, unionized, Democratic
educators and those working in “positive” school environments are less supportive of
school choice. Charter-school teachers are significantly more positive about school
choice than their public school counterparts, although they do not respond to the
same variables. The results can help illuminate the likely political prospects and
practical effects of choice-based reform.
Teachers College Record Volume 104, Number 8, December 2002, pp. 1568–1590
Copyright © by Teachers College, Columbia University
0161-4681