Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Fuel
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/fuel
Full Length Article
Influenceofestimatedphysicalconstantsandvaporpressureforestersinthe
methanol/ethanol recovery column for biodiesel production
Hugo A.D. Medeiros
a
, Osvaldo Chiavone-Filho
b
,RafaelB.Rios
a,
⁎
a
Departamento de Engenharia e Tecnologia, Universidade Federal Rural do Semi-Árido (UFERSA), 59625-900 Mossoró-RN, Brazil
b
Departamento de Engenharia Química, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Norte (UFRN), 59072-970 Natal-RN, Brazil
ARTICLEINFO
Keywords:
Vapor pressure
Physical constants
Properties estimation
Biodiesel
Aspen Hysys
ABSTRACT
The influence of the estimated values of the physical constants and vapor pressure of esters in a process si-
mulation using the Aspen Hysys was evaluated from the energy parameters of a methanol/ethanol recovery
distillationcolumnofabiodieselproductionplant.Thisstudywasnecessary,becauseinprocesssimulatorsmost
ofFAMEsandFAEEsarenotoriginallyavailableinthesimulatorlibrary,duetothelackofexperimentaldatafor
these components. Accuracy analyses for the values of reboiler temperature and reboiler heat duty of the si-
mulated column were performed from simulations using different predictive models and experimental data.
Resultsdemonstratedthatsmalldeviationsofthevaporpressurecangenerateconsiderableerrorsinthereboiler
temperatureandreboilerheatduty.Inaddition,errorscanbeevengreaterifvaporpressureisestimatedfrom
inaccuratecriticalconstants.Deviationsupto13%wereobservedforthereboilertemperatureandupto16%for
thereboilerheatduty.Itisdemonstratedthatreliablesimulationsandprocessdesignarestronglydependenton
the selected physical properties of the esters, specially vapor pressure, which are generated from available
experimental data and using group contribution and corresponding states models.
1. Introduction
Currently, the use of biofuels has received increasing attention,
mainly biodiesel use, that provides an alternative to replace fuels de-
rived from petroleum or as a blending component of conventional
dieselinvehicleengines [1].Biodieselisabiodegradableandnon-toxic
fuel and presents better gas emissions [2,3]. This fuel is defined as a
mixture of fatty acid alkyl esters (FAAEs) usually obtained by transes-
terificationreactionbetweentriglycerides(vegetableoiloranimalfat)
andshort-chainalcohol(primarilymethanolorethanol)inpresenceof
alkali-catalysts [1,4,5].
Moreover,thebiodieselproducedfrommethanolorethanolresults
in fatty acid methyl esters (FAMEs) or fatty acid ethyl esters (FAEEs),
respectively [4]. General studies on FAMEs are most commonly found
because of the low price of methanol [4]. Nonetheless, there is a
growinginterestintheuseofFAEEsinbiodiesel [6],sinceitpresentsa
higher cetane number and energy content, reflecting a better burning
and lower fuel consumption [7–9].
Inordertoincreasethefeasibilityofbiodieselproduction,different
homogeneous catalysts were evaluated [10–14], as well as hetero-
geneous [15–19]. Some authors have reported that the use of solid
catalysts returns high reaction rates and can even be easily removed
after the reaction [17,20,21], resulting advantages such as the exclu-
sion of purification steps, and consequently, the reduction in the
number of equipment units in the process [21,22]. Moreover, config-
urationsusingsupercriticalmethanolhavealsogainedprominencedue
tohigherreactionratewithouttheuseofcatalyst,leadingtoaprocess
intensification by the decrease of the separation step [5,23,24].
Given the difficulty of evaluating economically a biodiesel produc-
tion plant from these different routes, process simulation has been
presentedasanalternativetool.ThesesimulationsmustincludeFAMEs
or FAEEs species, which usually are not available in the simulator li-
brary, due to the lack of physical constants and vapor pressure data.
Thisoccursmainlyduetothedifficultyinobtainingtheseestersinpure
formsandincarryingouttheexperiments,becausethesesubstancesare
thermal sensible for degradation at severe conditions, especially near
their critical points [25].
Many studies may be found evaluating the economic viability of
biodiesel production plants from process simulations [21,26–28] or
have studied only biodiesel production through these simulators
[22,29,30]. However, none of these studies focused in evaluating
whether the thermodynamic model used is suitable for the mixture of
interest(triglyceride+alcohol+biodiesel+glycerin).Furthermore,
literature reports have not evaluated the ability of the available
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fuel.2020.118040
Received6March2020;Receivedinrevisedform5May2020;Accepted6May2020
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: rafael.rios@ufersa.edu.br (R.B. Rios).
Fuel 276 (2020) 118040
0016-2361/ © 2020 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
T