A method for constructing demographic profiles of Ovis orientalis/O. aries
using Logarithm Size Index scaling
Melinda A. Zeder
Department of Anthropology, National Museum of Natural History, Smithsonian Institution, 4955 Old Swimming Pool Road, Frederick, MD, 21703, USA
A R T I C L E INFO
Keywords:
Sheep
Sex-specific demographic profiles
Logarithm size index scaling
Zagros
Hunting
Herding
ABSTRACT
This paper presents a new method for constructing demographic profiles of archaeological sheep skeletal as-
semblages drawing on a method developed for Sus scrofa (Zeder and Lemoine, 2020a) and, most recently, for
goats (Zeder, 2024a). This method normalizes metric data using the Logarithm Size Index (LSI) scaling tech-
nique. LSI values of post-crania metric data of modern wild sheep from Iran and Iraq are shown to reflect strong
sexual dimorphism in body size which is evident in animals over one year of age. After adjustments to account for
the impacts of region and age on body size, along with differentials in the scaling of different elements, the mid-
point of the range of LSI values is shown to be a reliable and accurate way of distinguishing between the elements
of females and males that can then be used to construct sex-specific age profiles. This method is applied to metric
data from thirteen archaeological sheep skeletal assemblages from the Zagros Mountains of Iran and Iraq
spanning the period from the Middle Paleolithic to the Ceramic Neolithic. The resulting sex-specific demographic
profiles indicate that during pre-ceramic periods hunters practiced varied prey strategies that targeted different
segments of wild sheep populations. A clear signal of herding is detectable in Ceramic Neolithic assemblages
despite limitations in the recovery of unfused elements. The paper concludes by offering recommendations, and
caveats, to the use of this method for building sex-specific demographic profiles of ancient sheep assemblages.
1. Introduction
Age and sex-specific demographic profiling of archaeological faunal
assemblages can provide insights into the range of different harvest
strategies employed during the transition from the hunting of free-living
wild animals to the management of captive domesticates (Zeder,
2006a). This paper is the third in a series that employs the Logarithm
Size Index (LSI) scaling method for normalizing metric data to construct
age and sex harvest profiles of key prey/domesticate species during this
major transition. The first of these studies focused on wild boar and pig
(Sus scrofa) (Lemoine et al., 2014; Zeder et al., 2015; Zeder and Lemoine,
2020). The second presented a new demographic profiling method
based on LSI scaling for goats (Capra aegagrus/hircus) (Zeder, 2024a).
Here the focus is on applying this LSI scaling approach to a third major
prey/domesticate species— sheep (Ovis aries).
I begin with the analysis of modern Ovis skeletal collections from
Southwest Asia. After discussing the composition and history of these
modern collections, the impact of factors such as region, age, and skel-
etal element on log normalized metric data is examined. As in the earlier
study focusing on goats, the mid-point of a range of LSI values is found to
be a reliable boundary line for distinguishing between females and
males once the impact of region, element, and age are considered.
The accuracy of this method is then assessed by comparing actual
demographic profiles of the modern sheep sample against profiles
generated using the sex-assignments based on mid-point values. Once its
accuracy is demonstrated, this method is then employed in the analysis
of 13 archaeological assemblages of sheep skeletal elements from sites in
the Zagros region that extend in time from the Middle Paleolithic up to
the Ceramic Neolithic. Recommendations about the application of this
method to sheep, and other species, are offered at the end of this paper.
2. Modern sheep assemblage
The modern assemblage of wild sheep used in this study consists of a
total of 56 specimens curated by the Department of Mammals of the
Field Museum of Natural History (FMNH) (Table 1, Table S1). The
majority of these specimens were collected by the Street Expedition to
Iran in 1962–1963 and the Lay-Nadler Expedition to Iran in 1969 (Lay,
1967).
A total of seven general collecting localities are represented in the
E-mail address: zederm@si.edu.
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Journal of Archaeological Science
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jas
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jas.2025.106224
Received 26 January 2025; Received in revised form 5 April 2025; Accepted 7 April 2025
Journal of Archaeological Science 179 (2025) 106224
Available online 26 May 2025
0305-4403/© 2025 Elsevier Ltd. All rights are reserved, including those for text and data mining, AI training, and similar technologies.