Following the Fish, Mapping the Way:
Cod Routes, Fisher-Pilots and Early Maps
of the Grand Banks, 16th–19th Centuries
GAELLE DIEULEFET
a
, BRAD LOEWEN
b
AND BERNARD ALLAIRE
c
a
UFR Histoire, Histoire de l’Art et Archéologie, Université de Nantes,
Nantes, France;
b
Faculté des arts et des sciences, Département
d’anthropologie, Université de Montréal, Montréal, Québec, Canada;
c
Trinity Centre for Environmental Humanities, Trinity College Dublin,
Dublin, Ireland
This paper posits that relations between cod ecology, traditional piloting
practices, and transatlantic fishing methods underline the construction of
cartographic knowledge of the Atlantic coast of North America and the
Grand Banks in the 16th to 18th centuries. Based on an inventory of more
than 200 maps showing the Grand Banks from 1500 to 1825, we show
France’s preeminent role in mapping the Banks. We identify the early 16th-
century role of fisher-pilots in mapping the coastline and the accore, or outer
edge of the Banks, two corridors of abundant marine life. A new carto-
graphic idea, showing the Banks as a chain of plateaux, appears in 1543 and
increased from 1584 to 1630. Beginning in 1674, the French Admiralty
acquired and reproduced charts made by Basque and Breton cartographers
who had direct contact with fisher-pilots. The Admiralty began producing its
own charts after 1713, using a system of consulting fishing captains.
KEYWORDS Cartography; cod; fisheries; banks; Newfoundland
Cet article postule que les relations entre l’écologie de la morue, les
pratiques de pilotage traditionnelles et les méthodes de pêche transatlan-
tiques sous-tendent la construction de la connaissance cartographique de la
côte atlantique de l’Amérique du Nord et des Grands Bancs aux XVIe et
XVIIIe siècles. À partir d’un inventaire de plus de deux cents cartes
représentant les Grands Bancs de 1500 à 1825, nous démontrons le rôle
prééminent de la France dans la cartographie des Bancs. Une sélection de
TERRAE INCOGNITAE, Vol. 00, No. 00, 2025, 1–30
© 2025 The Society for the History of Discoveries DOI 10.1080/00822884.2025.2500255