Asian Journal of Engineering and Applied Technology
ISSN: 2249-068X (P)
Vol.13 No.2, 2024, pp.1-6
© Centre for Research and Innovation
www.crijournals.org
DOI: https://doi.org/10.70112/ajeat-2024.13.2.4239
Experimental Investigation of the Suitability of Surfactants Extracted
from Plant Leaves for Enhanced Oil Recovery
Bright Bariakpoa Kinate*, Godwin Chukwuma Jacob Nmegbu, Samson Wokike and Godloves Tondie Nonju
Department of Petroleum Engineering, Rivers State University, Port Harcourt, Nigeria
*Corresponding Author: kinate.bariakpoa@gmail.com
(Received 3 August 2024; Revised 22 August 2024, Accepted 15 September 2024; Available online 25 September 2024)
Abstract - The application of natural surfactants in enhanced
oil recovery has recently gained popularity due to their
environmentally friendly nature and low cost of production.
Several natural surfactants have been extracted from plant
leaves and tested for interfacial tension reduction and
increased oil recovery. However, it is important to evaluate the
oil recovery potential of natural surfactants extracted from
plant leaves that are abundant and available in each region for
easy production. This study evaluates the recovery potential of
surfactants produced from Citrus sinensis leaves, Carica
papaya leaves, and Garcinia kola leaves due to their saponin
contents for enhanced recovery while reducing the cost of
conventional surfactants. The plant leaves (Citrus sinensis,
Carica papaya, Garcinia kola) were washed, dried for one
week, ground, and measured in quantities of 2 grams and 4
grams. The measured quantities were added to 30 ml of hot
water, stirred to mix uniformly, and then brine was added to
fill up to 1000 ml in the cylinder. The solution was filtered to
obtain the surfactant extract. Core samples were saturated
with low salinity brine (10,000 ppm) and flooded with crude oil
until irreducible water saturation was achieved. The
breakthrough time and volume of water and oil recovered
were measured. The brine was replaced with the extracted
surfactants at concentrations of 2000 ppm and 4000 ppm, and
used for flooding. The volume of oil recovered for each
surfactant was measured. The results show that the Citrus
sinensis surfactant had an early breakthrough at 28 seconds
with 73.68% oil recovery, compared to the 4000 ppm dosage,
which had a breakthrough at 34 seconds with 77.5% oil
recovery. The Carica papaya surfactant at a 2000 ppm dosage
had a breakthrough at 33 seconds with an oil recovery of 85%,
and at 39 seconds with an 80.95% recovery for the 4000 ppm
dosage. The Garcinia kola surfactant had a late breakthrough
at 44 seconds with 76.08% oil recovery for the 2000 ppm
dosage and 80.00% recovery at 40 seconds breakthrough for
the 4000 ppm dosage. The Carica papaya surfactant provided
the highest oil recovery at the lowest dosage of 2000 ppm.
Keywords: Natural Surfactants, Oil Recovery, Plant Leaves,
Interfacial Tension, Saponin Contents
I. INTRODUCTION
Flooding with surfactants is one of the most efficient
methods for enhancing oil recovery through chemical
injection. The need to improve the recovery factor to above
50% to 60% of the original oil in place has arisen, driven by
chemical-enhanced methods [1]. This approach displaces
crude oil in the void spaces to the producing wells [2], [3].
The primary factors determining the selection and success
of flooding with surfactants include the structure, salinity
level, surfactant pH value, temperature, rock properties, and
adsorption behavior.
Surfactants come in various forms proposed for enhanced
oil recovery (EOR), including cationic, anionic, nonionic,
and natural surfactants. However, the application has
focused on natural surfactants as active agents for enhanced
oil recovery due to their effectiveness. Surfactant injection
into mature oil reservoirs as a chemical approach for EOR
has proven promising and effective [4], [5]. Surfactants
have been shown to decrease interfacial tension, modify
fluid-to-fluid and rock-to-fluid interactions, and increase
production [6], [7]. Many natural surfactants have been
extracted from various plant parts such as flowers, roots,
leaves, seeds, and oils, and have demonstrated the ability to
reduce interfacial tension and improve recovery [8], [9],
[10].
Additionally, animal and plant oils such as sesame oil,
coconut oil, and linseed oil have been processed into natural
surfactants for enhanced oil recovery and have shown good
performance [11], [12], [13]. For instance, A.B. Chhetri et
al., [14] extracted surfactants from the shell pericarp of
Mukurossi sapindus fruit to decrease the interfacial tension
(IFT) between oil and water, achieving over a 30%
reduction. Similarly, natural surfactants derived from
Seidlitzia rosea and Rosemary plants were used to decrease
interfacial tension and increase oil recovery, resulting in an
improved recovery factor [15]. Surfactants extracted from
Ziziphus spina-christi plant leaves were utilized for EOR
flooding in a carbonate reservoir, recording a significant
increase in oil recovery [16].
Likewise, S. Kumar et al., [17] investigated the suitability
of Glycyrrhizin glabra and Mulberry leaf surfactant extracts
in carbonate reservoirs, achieving an improved oil recovery
of 17.8% and 34% of the original oil in place. Cedar-
derived surfactants produced from mulberry tree leaves
were used to alter wettability in carbonate and sandstone
rocks, reducing the interfacial tension between water and
kerosene from 44 to 17.9 mN/m [18]. Surfactant extracts
from Matricaria chamomilla plants were tested for
interfacial tension reduction with kerosene as the oil phase
and distilled water, showing a decrease from 30.6 to 12.67
mN/m [19]. A. Khorram Ghahfarokhi et al., [20] evaluated
surfactants extracted from Prosopis leaves to reduce the
1 AJEAT Vol.13 No.2 July-December 2024