1
Impacts of advanced municipal wastewater treatment processes on
monochloramine effectiveness in recirculating cooling systems
Shih-Hsiang Chien
1
, David A. Dzombak
2
, and Radisav Vidic
1
1
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA, 15261, USA
2
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA
Email: shc52@pitt.edu
ABSTRACT
Chloramination is commonly used to prevent biological growth in drinking water distribution.
Recent studies also demonstrated the feasibility of using pre-formed monochloramine in power
plant recirculating cooling systems using secondary treated municipal wastewater (MWW) as
makeup. Despite its weak oxidizing ability, monochloramine was effective in controlling
biological growth in the cooling system and was more economical compared to other oxidizing
disinfectants (i.e., free chlorine and chlorine dioxide). However, due to severe scaling observed
in the systems using secondary effluent, it is necessary to employ advanced wastewater treatment
processes to make municipal wastewater suitable as makeup up water. In the present study,
nitrification, sand filtration, and granular activated carbon adsorption of secondary effluent were
evaluated for their impact on the operation of recirculating cooling using municipal wastewater
as the only makeup. The impact of these treatment processes on chloramination was determined
based on the biocidal effectiveness against heterotrophic bacteria and Legionella, percentage of
active monochloramine residual in the recirculating water, and total disinfectant requirement to
achieve a desired residual.
Laboratory- and pilot-scale studies indicated that a monochloramine residual of 2-3 mg/L as Cl
2
is required to control biological growth in the cooling system using secondary effluent treated
with nitrification and sand filtration (MWW_NF). Removal of ammonia and organic matter
through nitrification significantly reduced the formation of organic chloramines and helped to
maintain active monochloramine residual at 85% of total chlorine residual. Further removal of
organic carbon by GAC showed no measurable improvement. Furthermore, monochloramine
residual around 2 mg/L was unable to control the planktonic biological growth in GAC-treated
MWW_NF (MWW_NFG). It is important to note that monochloramine was successful in
controlling growth of Legionella in all three wastewaters during 2 months of pilot-scale testing.
MWW_NF was also the most suitable makeup in terms of biocide requirement to maintain a
desired residual. Use of nitrification and sand filtration of secondary treated wastewater is
essential to effective use of monochloramine for biofouling control when using treated municipal
wastewater as makeup in power plant recirculating cooling systems.
KEYWORDS: Wastewater Treatment, Biofouling, Monochloramine, Cooling System
4658
WEFTEC 2012
Copyright ©2012 Water Environment Federation. All Rights Reserved.