Qeios
PEER-APPROVED
v1: 11 December 2024
Research Article
Comparison of Clinical and
Radiological Diagnosis with
Autopsy Findings in Fatal
Trac Accident Cases
Peer-approved: 11 December 2024
© The Author(s) 2024. This is an
Open Access article under the CC BY
4.0 license.
Qeios, Vol. 6 (2024)
ISSN: 2632-3834
Dr Ambika Prasad Patra
1
, Kagne Rajeswari R.
2
, Vinod Chaudhari
3
,
Balamurugan N.
2
, Deepu Mathew
3
1. Faculty of Medicine, Department of Forensic Medicine and Toxicology, Jawaharlal Institute of
Postgraduate Medical Education and Research, India; 2. Department of Emergency Medicine, Jawaharlal
Institute of Postgraduate Medical Education and Research, India; 3. Department of Forensic Medicine
and Toxicology, Jawaharlal Institute of Postgraduate Medical Education and Research, India
This study investigated the alignment between clinical and radiological
assessments and autopsy ndings in fatal road trac accidents (RTAs),
focusing on the identication of missed injuries and diagnostic
discrepancies. Conducted at a tertiary care centre in India, this study
examined 146 cases of RTA fatalities over a two-year period.
Clinicoradiological diagnoses were compared with autopsy ndings across
various injury types, including head, thoracic, abdominal, and limb injuries.
Autopsy ndings revealed a higher incidence of certain injuries, such as
cervical spine injuries, cerebral contusions, and small haemorrhages, which
were often missed during the initial clinical and radiological evaluations.
Injury agreement was statistically evaluated using kappa statistics, revealing
a moderate to slight correlation in most cases, with specic areas of notable
discordance. In 21.9% of the cases, the cause of death determined clinically
diered from autopsy ndings, underscoring the critical role of autopsy in
rening trauma assessment protocols and improving diagnostic accuracy.
These ndings highlight the value of autopsy feedback for emergency trauma
care and suggest a need for advanced diagnostic techniques to reduce missed
injuries in polytrauma cases.
Corresponding author: Ambika Prasad Patra,
drambikajipmer@outlook.com
Introduction
The incidence of trac accidents is increasing, as are
the associated mortality and morbidity rates.
According to the 2023 World Health Organization
(WHO) data, road trac accidents (RTA) result in the
loss of approximately 1.19 million lives annually, and
20 to 50 million individuals sustain non-fatal injuries,
with a signicant proportion experiencing permanent
disabilities
[1] [2]
. Over 90% of road trac fatalities
occur in low- and middle-income countries, despite
these nations possessing only 60% of the world's
vehicles. Consequently, the majority of countries
incur a cost of approximately 3 to 5% of their Gross
Domestic Product (GDP)
[1]
.
Road trac accidents frequently involve multiple
injuries that aect various body systems. These
injuries can lead to signicant disabilities and pose
life-threatening risks. Globally, motor vehicle
accidents are the primary cause of polytraumas
[1]
.
qeios.com
doi.org/10.32388/TJ22UQ.2
1