Original Article
World J Oncol • 2010;1(4):158-166
Press Elmer
Articles © The authors | Journal compilation © World J Oncol and Elmer Press™ | www.wjon.org
Role of Radionuclide Therapy as Adjuvant to Palliative
External Beam Radiotherapy for Painful Multiple
Skeletal Metastasis
Ayse Hicsonmez
a, d
, Ozlem N. Kucuk
b
, Meltem Nalca Andrieu
a
, Yildiz Guney
c
, Erkan Ibis
b
Abstract
Background: The aim of this study was to evaluate the palliative
efficacy of localized external radiotherapy (RT) combined with sys-
temic radionuclide (RN) therapy in patients who had multiple pain-
ful osseous metastases of different primary origins.
Methods: Thirty-three patients initially local external radiother-
apy was delivered to the most symptomatic region in all patients.
Then they received either Re 186 HEDP or Sm 153 EDTMP. The
performance status was assessed according to ECOG scale. Before
treatment, at the end of the radiotherapy and after the four weeks
of systemic radionuclide therapy, analgesic intake and pain status
were recorded by the RTOG scoring system, and EORTC QLQ C30
(Version 3.0 Turkish) questionnaire was performed to evaluate the
quality of life.
Results: Improved performances of 33.3% for post radiation ther-
apy and 50% for post radionuclide therapy in the ECOG scale were
observed. Statistically significant correlations were found between
the primary origins and decreased pain and analgesic intake (p <
0.05), but no differences were observed on the self assessment qual-
ity of life questionnaire.
Conclusions: Both Re 186 HEDP, Sm 153 EDTMP are effective
and safe in bone pain palliation as an adjuvant to local field radia-
tion therapy of breast and prostate cancer patients, who also contin-
ued to receive chemotherapy and/or hormontherapy.
Keywords: Bone metastases; Radiotherapy; Radionuclide therapy
Introduction
Bone metastasis is a common, challenging problem in pa-
tients with advanced cancer. Although they are often clini-
cally silent, they may lead to serious complications such as
pain, fractures and hypercalcemia, which result in reduce
performance status and decrease the quality of life. The
life expectancy of the patients with bone metastases varies
widely, depending on tumor types [1]. Management of bone
pain can be maintained with analgesia, radiation, hormones,
chemotherapy and surgery. Localized sites of bone involve-
ment can be treated with surgery, radiofrequency ablation or
external beam radiotherapy, whereas radiopharmaceuticals,
hormones and chemotherapy are used to treat more diffuse
bone involvement.
Radiation therapy and surgery are used for the treatment
of localized bone metastases. The goal of localized irradia-
tion is to relieve symptoms, restore function and prevent
the sequelae of disease progression in the area treated [2-
6]. Despite the lack of a dose response relationship for lo-
cal field radiation therapy, different dose fractionations have
been recommended [7]. Some patients with extensive dis-
ease are candidates for hemibody irradiation, however this
treatment is associated with a high incidence of side effects
[8]. Response rates are reported to be higher than 70%, and
complete relief of pain has been achieved in 20% of patients
[9,10]. On the other hand, systemic radionuclide therapy
represents a better approach for patients who have multiple
bone metastatic sites. In recent years it has been employed
with increasing frequency [11-14]. The advantages of tar-
geted radionuclide therapy are the simultaneous treatment of
all affected areas and the fact that it shows tumor specificity
with relative sparing of the surrounding tissue. Patients can
usually benefit from a single injection and pain relief may be
obtained within the first week of treatment, which lasts for
Manuscript accepted for publication August 13, 2010
a
Ankara University School of Medicine Department of Radiation
Oncology, Turkey
b
Ankara University School of Medicine Department of Nuclear
Medicine, Turkey
c
Ankara Oncology Hospital, Department of Radiation Oncology,
Ankara, Turkey
d
Corresponding author: Ankara University School of Medicine
Department of Radiation Oncology, Cebeci Hospital, Dikimevi,
Ankara, 06100 Turkey. E-mail: asonmez@medicine.ankara.edu.tr
doi:10.4021/wjon235w
158