REPLICATION OF CHIMERIC YELLOW FEVER VIRUS-DENGUE SEROTYPE 1-4
VIRUS VACCINE STRAINS IN DENDRITIC AND HEPATIC CELLS
SAMANTHA BRANDLER, NATHAN BROWN, THOMAS H. ERMAK, FRED MITCHELL, MEGAN PARSONS,
ZHENXI ZHANG, JEAN LANG, THOMAS P. MONATH, AND FARSHAD GUIRAKHOO
Institute of Virology, Medical University of Vienna, Vienna, Austria; Acambis, Inc. Cambridge, Massachusetts; Aventis Pasteur,
Campus Merieux, Marcy-L’Etoile, France
Abstract. ChimeriVax™-dengue (DEN) viruses are live attenuated vaccine candidates. They are constructed by
replacing the premembrane (prM) and envelope (E) genes of the yellow fever (YF) 17D virus vaccine with the
corresponding genes from wild-type DEN viruses (serotypes 1-4) isolated from humans. In this study, the growth kinetics
of ChimeriVax™-DEN1-4 and parent viruses (wild-type DEN-1-4 and YF 17D) were assessed in human myeloid
dendritic cells (DCs) and in three hepatic cell lines (HepG2, Huh7, and THLE-3). In DC, ChimeriVax™-DEN-1-4
showed similar growth kinetics to their parent viruses, wild-type DEN virus (propagated in Vero cells), or YF 17D virus
(peak titers ∼3-4.5 log
10
plaque-forming units (PFU)/mL at 48-72 hours post-infection). Parent wild-type DEN-1-4
viruses derived from C6/36 mosquito cells did not show any growth at a multiplicity of infection of 0.1 in DCs, except
for DEN-2 virus, which grew to a modest titer of 2.5 log
10
PFU/mL at 48 hours post-infection. ChimeriVax™-DEN1-4
grew to significantly lower titers (2-5 log
10
PFU/mL) than YF 17D virus in hepatic cell lines THLE-3 and HepG2, but
not in Huh7 cells. These experiments suggest that ChimeriVax™-DEN1-4 viruses replicate similarly to YF-VAX in
DCs, but at a lower level than YF 17D virus in hepatic cell lines. The lack of growth of chimeric viruses in human hepatic
cells suggests that these viruses may be less hepatotropic than YF 17D virus vaccine in humans.
INTRODUCTION
Dengue (DEN) virus is a mosquito born flavivirus that in-
fects 100 million people annually and causes 24,000 deaths in
tropical and sub-tropical areas. There are four serotypes of
DEN virus, all of which can result in severe forms of the
disease known as dengue hemorrhagic fever/dengue shock
syndrome (DHF/DSS). Prior infection by one DEN virus se-
rotype increases the likelihood of acquiring DHF/DSS upon
exposure to a second DEN virus serotype.
1
Thus, the ratio-
nale for successful vaccination requires simultaneous vaccina-
tion against all four serotypes.
ChimeriVax™-DEN1-4 is a tetravalent live attenuated vac-
cine composed of four chimeric yellow fever (YF) 17D-DEN
viruses. Each chimera was constructed by removing the pre-
membrane (prM) and envelope (E) genes of the YF 17D
virus, and replacing them with the genes of one of the four
serotypes of DEN virus.
2
Because of the chimeric nature of
these viruses, we were interested in comparing the replication
and tissue tropism of the vaccine strains to the parental vi-
ruses using dendritic cells (DCs) and hepatic cell lines.
Myeloid immature DCs are found in most non-lymphoid
organs, and form a network in the epidermis where they are
also known as Langerhans cells. After capture and processing
of a pathogen, immature DCs are activated and differentiate
into mature DCs that migrate under the control of interleu-
kin-1 to draining lymph nodes where they are responsible
for antigen presentation, T cell activation, and stimulation of
memory cells.
3,4
Langerhans cells are critical to the induction
of immune responses to foreign antigens introduced into the
skin. In a natural infection, DEN virus is introduced into the
skin of the vertebrate host by the bite of an infected mosquito.
Macrophages and monocytes were thought to be initial target
cells for DEN infection, but recent studies have shown that
DCs are 10-fold more permissive for DEN infection and rep-
lication than either macrophages or monocytes.
5–8
The in-
creased infectivity is facilitated by use of the DC-specific in-
tercellular adhesion molecule 3-grabbing nonintegrin (DC-
SIGN) receptor.
9,10
To our knowledge, there are no published
reports showing replication of wild-type YF or YF 17D vac-
cine viruses in DCs, although another flavivirus, West Nile
virus, has been reported to replicate in DCs.
11
Due to the
important role of DCs in initiating an immune response, we
selected these cells for comparison of the growth kinetics of
ChimeriVax™-DEN1-4 versus YF 17D virus as well as the
four wild-type DEN virus serotypes (wild-type DEN1-4).
We also addressed the hepatotropism of ChimeriVax™-
DEN1-4 in hepatic cell lines. Yellow fever 17D and DEN
viruses exhibit different patterns of hepatic infection. The YF
17D virus vaccine was developed in 1936 by empirical passage
of wild-type YF virus in mouse and chick embryos. Although
the vaccine virus has lost its viscerotropism and exhibited a
marked reduction in neurovirulence properties for monkeys,
there has been a number of serious adverse events (AEs)
associated with this vaccine, resulting in encephalitis or he-
patic failure.
12
During the course of DEN virus infection, the
pathology of the liver is generally mild and resembles that of
the early stages of YF virus infection, with less severe symp-
toms such as limited lesions in the liver and mild foci of ne-
crosis. The presence of DEN viral antigens in human hepa-
tocytes from patients with dengue fever, demonstration of
apoptosis in Kupffer cells, and productive replication in hu-
man hepatoma cell lines (HepG2, Huh7) suggest that the liver
can be targeted by DEN viruses.
13–19
Because severe hepatic
failure with YF 17D virus (at a rate of 1:400,000)
20
and
potential infection of the liver with DEN virus (DEN virus
was recovered from 5 of 17 livers of children suspected to
have died of dengue)
21
have been reported, the hepatotro-
pism of the chimeric YF-DEN1-4 viruses for humans (in vivo)
may only be revealed by monitoring vaccine-related AEs af-
ter inoculation of large numbers of humans. To compare the
hepatotropism of these chimeras to that of YF 17D and wild-
type DEN viruses in vitro, we measured the growth kinetics of
these viruses in three hepatic cell lines: HepG2, Huh7, and
THLE-3.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Cell lines. Normal human dendritic cells (NHDCs) were
obtained from Cambrex Bio Science (Walkersville, MD).
Am. J. Trop. Med. Hyg., 72(1), 2005, pp. 74–81
Copyright © 2005 by The American Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene
74