Research Article
Qualitative Health Research
2024, Vol. 0(0) 1–13
© The Author(s) 2024
Article reuse guidelines:
sagepub.com/journals-permissions
DOI: 10.1177/10497323241274723
journals.sagepub.com/home/qhr
“Accepting the Poem of Destiny”: Identity
Reconstruction in a Chinese Online
Depression Community
Xin Li
1
and Kaibin Xu
2
Abstract
As online health communities become important platforms for people with depression to express themselves, digital
narratives provide a lens for understanding their identity work. Drawing on the communication theory of identity (CTI),
this article explored the members’ identity reconstruction by analyzing their narratives posted in a Chinese online
depression community. The four levels of identities constructed by the members include “laggard” and “pioneer” at the
personal layer, “idler” and “fighter” at the enacted level, “stress-maker” and “escaper” at the relational layer, and support
providers and receivers at the communal layer. These identities at different levels usually interact in the narratives,
showing that identity gaps exist among the members. The study shows that the members’ autobiographical accounts of
depression entail multiplicities and ambivalences, denying the dominant and stigmatizing representation of it by common
sense and the media as a reductionist downward and one-way experience that is valueless and offers no possibility for
personal growth. The findings regarding the communal level of identity show that narratives can help the narrators to
create bonds of solidarity of an experience that is often marginalized.
Keywords
depression; identity; illness narrative; digital narrative; online health community
Depression is one of the most common types of psy-
chiatric disorders and refers to an individual “who, for
2 weeks or longer, becomes depressed, loses interest, or is
unable to feel happy in everyday activities, accompanied
by problems in specific areas such as sleep, eating, energy,
concentration, or self-worth” (American Psychiatric
Association, 2013). By affecting the individual both
physically and mentally, depression increases the health
risks of the individual (WHO, 2022). It also disrupts
individuals’ social functioning and their ability to function
in the family, school, and performance at work (Lerner
et al., 2010). The prevalence of depression and the rel-
evant social consequences have made it a major public
health issue affecting the globe. China has approximately
more than 54 million people suffering from depression,
among whom 30 million are adolescents (Depression
Research Institute, 2020). Depression among college
students has also become a common social phenomenon
(Liu et al., 2019). The chronic, recurrent, and harmful
nature of depression disrupts people’s daily life and
conception of the self. In the face of identity threats posed
by major life changes, people often make identity
adjustments and create new identities to adapt to current
life circumstances, such as modifying goals and expec-
tations for the future, adapting to the harm, and under-
standing emotional responses (Voorhees, 2023).
Managing the impact of the illness and normalizing life is
a manifestation of the affected individual’s adoption of the
new identity (Charmaz & Rosenfeld, 2010). However,
stigmatization in society and mass media influences the
identity reconstruction of people living with depression.
As a form of negative feedback, stigmatization not only
undermines the well-being of people with depression but
also leads them to develop an identity crisis and reduces
1
College of Communication Science and Art, Chengdu University of
Technology, Chengdu, China
2
Foreign Studies College, Hunan Normal University, Changsha, China
Corresponding Author:
Kaibin Xu, Foreign Studies College, Hunan Normal University,
Changsha 410081, China.
Email: 2103477077@qq.com