Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 141 (2021) 110768
Available online 31 January 2021
1364-0321/© 2021 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Public transportation with electric traction: Experiences and challenges in
an Andean city
L.G. Gonz´ alez
a
, Daniel Cordero-Moreno
b
, J.L. Espinoza
a, *
a
Department of Electrical, Electronics and Telecommunications Engineering (DEET), Universidad de Cuenca, Cuenca, 010107, Ecuador
b
Universidad del Azuay, Av. 24 de Mayo 7-77, Cuenca, Ecuador
A R T I C L E INFO
Keywords:
Battery-electric bus
Public transport
Energy demand
Andean cities
Renewable energy
ABSTRACT
The paper studies the energy behavior of a battery-electric bus (BEB) operating on commercial routes as well as
the technical feasibility of a total replacement of the current public transport fleet by BEBs in an Andean city. The
electrical variables in the BEB charging process are evaluated obtaining THD current distortions of less than 4%,
values that meet national and international standards. Regarding the energy demand, the study uses an estimate
that allows quantifying the energy consumption of the fleet of 424 BEBsthat would operate the 28 routes. It is
estimated that the maximum demand during the charging process can reach 33.92 MW if the fleet is charged at a
rate of 80 kW per BEB and 19.96 MW if the charge is at 40 kW, whereas the charging time can range from 4 h to
9 h, respectively. The daily energy needed to power the fleet is 115 MWh, which represents about 4% of energy
demanded per day by the city. The estimation of the energy efficiency of the BEB under analysis presents values
that vary between 0.67 and 0.94 km/kWh, an indicator that depends on the conditions of the route. The article
includes and study on the preference of BEB users as compared to conventional buses. Finally, the study shows a
feasible alternative to integrate renewable energy sources for BEB charging, based on photovoltaic solar gen-
eration and the use of energy storage systems, as a contribution to the sustainability of the public transport.
1. Introduction
Primary energy for electricity generation and transportation repre-
sents currently around 60% of the total consumed in the world [1].
If it is consider the high dependence of our development model on
the use of fossil fuels, whose emissions have a negative impact on the
climate and ecosystems, renewable energy sources (RE) for electricity
generation and transport electrification present a great potential for a
transition to a new energy paradigm [1]. There are multiple interna-
tional efforts, such as the Kyoto protocol or the most recent Paris
agreement, that look for reducing greenhouse gas emissions, particu-
larly CO
2
, through the development of new technologies that contribute
to a cleaner and more efficient electricity generation matrix as well as to
a sustainable mobility. Electric vehicles (EV) are a clear example to
promote the change towards the use of more efficient and environ-
mentally friendly means of transportation. Additionally, among the
most important challenges to advance towards sustainable mobility are:
increasing the quality of public transport, improving urban planning,
promoting shared transport, or the massive use of bicycles, thus chal-
lenging the exponential growth of private cars that occurs in many cities
around the world [2,3]. If EV can be powered by electricity from
renewable sources, then the positive impact would be twofold and we
would be moving towards a more sustainable energy model.
In terms of public policy for the promotion of RE and EV, recently in
the Republic of Ecuador there have been a series of events that arouse
the research interest in different areas. For example, the Ecuadorian
Constitution, in its article 413, establishes that the State must promote
energy efficiency, the development and use of environmentally clean
and healthy practices and technologies, as well as renewable, diversi-
fied, low-impact energies that do not jeopardize food sovereignty, the
ecological balance of ecosystems or the right to water [4]. In October
2018, the country’s Electricity Regulation and Control Agency (ARCO-
NEL) approved regulation ARCONEL-003/18 where solar
photovoltaic-based generation for self-consumption of final users is
allowed, opening the possibility that this small-scale energy can be
connected to the national interconnected system - SNI [5]. In March
2019, the Energy Efficiency Law was ratified by the National Assembly
[6], where article 14, on energy efficiency in transport, indicates that
from the year 2025 all vehicles that join the urban and inter-parish
public transport service must only be electric traction-based. Added to
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: juan.espinoza@ucuenca.edu.ec (J.L. Espinoza).
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews
journal homepage: http://www.elsevier.com/locate/rser
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2021.110768
Received 28 August 2020; Received in revised form 2 January 2021; Accepted 25 January 2021