RESEARCH ARTICLE
Choosing Wisely for apheresis
Laura Connelly-Smith
1
| Yvette C. Tanhehco
2
| Vishesh Chhibber
3
| Meghan Delaney
4
|
Quentin Eichbaum
5
| Christine Fernandez
6
| Sarita Joshi
7
| Joseph Schwartz
2
| Michael Linenberger
1
1
University of Washington and Fred Hutchinson
Cancer Research Center, Seattle, Washington
2
Columbia University Irving Medical Center,
New York, New York
3
Northwell Health, Manhasset, New York
4
Children's National Health System, Washington,
District of Columbia
5
Vanderbilt University, Nashville, Tennessee
6
Consultant, Denver, Colorado
7
Cleveland Clinic Foundation, Cleveland, Ohio
Correspondence
Dr Michael Linenberger, Fred Hutchinson Cancer
Research Center (D5280), 1100 Fairview Avenue
N. Seattle, WA 98109.
Email: linen@u.washington.edu
Abstract
The Choosing Wisely campaign has stimulated clinicians to think about the appro-
priateness of various tests and procedures, compelling physicians to make smarter,
safer and more effective choices for high quality patient care and to reduce health-
care cost. The American Society for Apheresis (ASFA) strives to advance apheresis
medicine through education, evidence-based practice, research and advocacy. To
complement these shared missions, ASFA created a working group, consisting of
representatives from the various ASFA committees, to produce recommendations
for apheresis medicine that reflect the Choosing Wisely guiding principles. A
diverse group of ASFA physician and allied health members reviewed, rated and
ranked 9 original draft proposals. Additional revisions and refinements were made
prior to external review and adoption of five final recommendations by the ASFA
Board of Directors. The ASFA Choosing Wisely recommendations encourage
apheresis practitioners, patients and donors to discuss and prioritize best clinical
practices that avoid harm and waste while optimizing clinical benefit.
KEYWORDS
choosing wisely, coagulation tests, red blood cell exchange, therapeutic plasma
exchange, venous access
1 | INTRODUCTION
Choosing Wisely is an initiative of the American Board of
Internal Medicine (ABIM) Foundation that seeks to advance
dialog between patients and physicians on avoiding unneces-
sary medical tests, treatments and procedures.
1
This initiative
was initially sparked by a “Perspective” article published in
2010, calling on U.S. medical specialty societies to identify
five tests and treatments that were overused in their specialty
and did not provide meaningful benefit for patients.
2
Some
estimates suggest that as much as 30% of all health care
spending is wasted.
3
In 2012, the ABIM Foundation and
Consumer Reports launched the Choosing Wisely campaign,
inspired by the idea that professional societies and health
care providers should take the lead in defining and motivat-
ing efforts to reduce the use of low-value care.
4,5
Since its launch, the Choosing Wisely campaign has
grown rapidly and spread to 20 countries, with over 70 par-
ticipating medical societies.
5
Multiple national organizations
representing various medical specialties have identified tests
or procedures commonly used in their field whose necessity
should be questioned.
The American Society for Apheresis (ASFA) is an orga-
nization comprised of health care professionals involved in
apheresis from 45 states across America and in 35 countries
around the world. The mission of ASFA is to advance aphe-
resis medicine through education, evidence-based practice,
research and advocacy. The collaboration was formed
between ASFA and the ABIM Foundation’s Choosing
Wisely initiative in 2016 to develop a list of 5 overused
apheresis practices that should prompt discussion between
patients and physicians. This manuscript describes the
process and methodology used by ASFA to develop final
recommendations for Choosing Wisely.
Laura Conelly Smith and Yvette C. Tanhehco contributed equally to this
study.
Received: 29 March 2018 Revised: 22 May 2018 Accepted: 1 June 2018
DOI: 10.1002/jca.21643
576 © 2018 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/jca J Clin Apher. 2018;33:576–579.