POWER CONSUMPTION ESTIMATION MODELS FOR FIR DECIMATION
FILTERS IN MULTI-STANDARD RECEIVERS
Nadia Khouja
(1)
, Khaled Grati
(1)
, Bertrand Le Gal
(2)
, Adel Ghazel
(1)
1
CIRTA’COM Laboratory, Ecole Supérieure des Communications de Tunis, Ariana, Tunisia
2
IMS Laboratory, Université de Bordeaux I, Bordeaux, France
ABSTRACT
Many communications embedded systems implement
decimation filters. In particular, base-band stage in
multistandard receivers is composed of cascade of deci-
mation filters performing channel selection. The number
of used filter and the kind of these filters can have a sig-
nificant impact on the computation complexity and power
consumption of multistandard receivers. In This work we
present FIR filters’ power consumption estimation models.
Models were obtained from a large number of FIR filter
syntheses using direct and polyphase forms. Several
curves that estimate power consumption were extracted
from these experimental results. The idea behind this work
is to use the obtained models and curves to help filter de-
signer to make the right choice regarding decimation fac-
tor versus power consumption.
Index Terms— Multistandard receiver, decimation
filter, power consumption, polyphase decomposition, estimation
model
1. INTRODUCTION
Nowadays, wireless technologies are widespread thanks to
their flexibility of use. However many different standard
are used and the new challenge of the communication Em-
bedded system designer is to implement multiple commu-
nication standards devices providing easy access to infor-
mation everywhere with low hardware complexity. In
general, in such devices, communication chains include
decimation and selector filters. Typically, multiple stan-
dards communication chains are composed of RF front-end
followed by an over-sampler analog to digital converter
then by a cascade of decimation filters (Fig. 1) [1].
RF filter
Analog to
Digital
Converter
FIR
decimation
filter
Figure 1. General communication chain in a multi-standard re-
ceiver
The power consumption is an important constraint during
embedded system design. Hence, the design of decimation
filters has a deep impact on the power consumption in
multi-standard receiver. FIR filters are used to perform
decimation and channel selection filters because they guar-
antee linear phase. The poly-phase form of FIR filters is
widely recommended for reducing power consumption in
comparison to all possible implementation forms of these
filters. However, we were not able to find in the literature a
clear study based on experimental results showing how
much power consumption FIR filters consumes and how
much poly-phase form could save. In fact, we found that
the reference [2] is widely mentioned. But this work deals
only with power consumption, area and critical path of a
particular implementation of comb filter. It was shown in
this work that appropriate filter decomposition in associa-
tion with poly-phase decomposition could lead to an im-
portant power consumption of the Comb filter.
The idea of this paper is to give models evaluating FIR
decimator filters power consumption in direct form and
polyphase implementation form. These models take into
consideration main filter parameters: filter order, input
wordlength and coefficient wordlength. The impact of the
poly-phase decomposition form on the power consumption
and area occupation for FIR filters is deeply studied in this
work in ASIC technology and using a 65-nm low power
library of STMicroelectronics.
The objective of the study is to help filter designer to
decide about the best way to decompose the filter process-
ing into stages in order to guarantee optimal power con-
sumption.
This paper is organized as following: Section II presents
the methodology used to estimate both power consumption
and area occupation of FIR filter. In section III, we present
the obtained results for direct implementation form on
ASIC technology using a 65-nm STMicroelectronics li-
brary. In section IV, we discussed results obtained for the
polyphase implementation form in the same ASIC technol-
ogy. Finally, conclusions are given in section V.
2. DECIMATOR FIR FILTER POWER
CONSUMPTION CHARACTERIZATION
When designing a FIR channel selection and decimation
filter, filter designer faces a trade-off between channel se-
lection efficiency and filter complexity. In fact, the design
has to guarantee an appropriate selection of the useful sig-
2011 IEEE GCC Conference and Exhibition (GCC), February 19-22, 2011, Dubai, United Arab Emirates
978-1-61284-119-9/11/$26.00 ©2011 IEEE 617