Chapter
3
From
the
Psychologization
of
Experience
tothe Priority of Emotions inSocial Life
Lourdes Flamarique
Introduction
f
Ithas become commonplace
tostudy theubiquity of emotions inmany areas of
contemporary
culture.
However
contemporary
the inquiry
may seem,
the role of
emotions
in
social
life
was
highlighted
long
ago
bythe
Greeks.
Plato,
for
example,
criticized poetry and plays that present false ethical conduct and models because
oftheemotions and feelings that their plots and characters arouse intheviewer.
He emphasized that poetry's emotional force has the ability to master the audience
through imitation tothe point of obscuring truth. Also Aristotle, inhis Rhetoric,
largely
attributes
the power of
persuasion
tothe
emotions,
a power
that should be
ver of
taken into account inpublic affairs.
Partly because ofthe influence ofthe stoics,
medieval
ethics
pays
attention
tothe power ofpassion
and emotion
inhuman
behavior.
Still,
not
until late
modernity
does an
explanation
of
contemporary
panemotivism"
emerge. The purpose
ofthis chapter istoprovide such an
explanation.
Tobegin with, the word "panemotivism"¹
contains a judgment: it considers
that our culture and the ways ofbeing therein are marked byan imbalance divided
oftho
bythe rationality ofthe objective social sphere and the hyper-emotionality ofthe
subjective sphere. Inthis discussion we are not somuch after the nature of emotions,
their
variety andthe different
networks
combined
tomake semantic possibilities
rtainty abont
unpredictable because theemotions are characterized bygreat uncertainty about
the meanings that they present. What is ofinterest here, rather, is the imbalance-
the hypertrophy of emotions contrasted with themodern project that seems tobe,
in consequence, buta variant ofthe internal dialectic of enlightened modernity.
a
ndidentif
Tobest understand human affairs, one must consider their origin and identify
the factors involved, and sotoo with emotion. "Feeling is everything," says
Goethe's Faust. Yet, what is this "everything" identified asfeeling or emotion?
With Romanticism, feelings and emotions refer mainly to
experiences
that touch
on the innermost being ofthe self. While once emotions
and passions
were felt on
1 Mestrovic's diagnosis provides an interesting approach tothe same topic, defining
our society as post-emotional based onthe mechanization of emotions (Mestrovic 1997).
2 "Gefühl istalles."