Jealousy and partner preference
among butch and femme lesbians
Jonathan Bassett, Sharon Pearcey, and
James M. Dabbs Jr
Georgia State University
Abstract
The present study examined the differences in partner preference and
jealousy among lesbians who identied themselves as butch or femme.
We hypothesized that butch and femme lesbians would behave
analogously to male and female heterosexual persons, with butches more
attracted to a partner’s physical appearance and more jealous of a partner’s
sexual behaviour and femmes more attracted to a partner’s nancial
resources and more jealous of a partner’s emotional behaviour. Eighty-four
lesbian women attending a Gay Pride celebration ranked the attributes,
that would make them most jealous of potential competitors in whom
their partner might be interested, and they rated their willingness to go
out with hypothetical others who varied in physical attractiveness,
income, and masculine or feminine personality. Results indicated that
butches and femmes did not differ in sexual versus emotional jealousy.
However, femmes were more inuenced by the nancial resources of
potential partners than were butches. Butches and femmes also differed as
to which attributes of a competitor made them the most jealous. Femmes
were more jealous of a physically attractive competitor, and butches were
more jealous of a wealthy competitor. While the labels butch and femme
have often been characterized as social constructions modelled after
heterosexual sex roles and applied to lesbians by outside observers, the
results of the present study provide further evidence that they are more
than that. The present ndings, consistent with other research, suggest
that a complex interaction of socialization and prenatal development
underlie lesbian sex role identication.
Psychology, Evolution & Gender 3.2 August 2001 pp. 155–165
Psychology, Evolution & Gender
ISSN 1461-6661 print/ISSN 1470-1073 online © 2001 Taylor & Francis Ltd
http://www.tandf.co.uk/journals
DOI: 10.1080/1461666011006737 5