Molecular Ecology (2004) 13, 2655–2666 doi: 10.1111/j.1365-294X.2004.02281.x
© 2004 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
Blackwell Publishing, Ltd.
Partitioning nuclear and chloroplast variation at multiple
spatial scales in the neotropical epiphytic orchid,
Laelia rubescens
DORSET W. TRAPNELL * and J. L. HAMRICK †
*Department of Plant Biology, University of Georgia, Athens, Georgia 30602, †Departments of Plant Biology and Genetics, University
of Georgia, Athens, Georgia 30602
Abstract
Insights into processes that lead to the distribution of genetic variation within plant species
require recognition of the importance of both pollen and seed movement. Here we investigate
the contributions of pollen and seed movement to overall gene flow in the Central American
epiphytic orchid, Laelia rubescens. Genetic diversity and structure were examined at
multiple spatial scales in the tropical dry forest of Costa Rica using nuclear (allozymes) and
chloroplast restriction fragment length polymorphism ( RFLP) markers, which were found
to be diverse (allozymes, P = 73.3%; H
E
= 0.174; cpDNA, H
E
= 0.741). Nuclear genetic structure
(F
STn
) was low at every spatial scale (0.005 – 0.091). Chloroplast markers displayed more
structure (0.073 – 0.254) but relatively similar patterns. Neither genome displayed significant
isolation-by-distance. Pollen and seed dispersal rates did not differ significantly from one
another (m
p
/m
s
= 1.40) at the broadest geographical scale, among sites throughout Costa Rica.
However, relative contributions of pollen and seeds to gene flow were scale-dependent,
with different mechanisms determining the dominant mode of gene flow at different spatial
scales. Much seed dispersal is highly localized within the maternal population, while some
seeds enter the air column and are dispersed over considerable distances. At the intermediate
scale (10s to 100s of metres) pollinators are responsible for substantial pollen flow. This
species appears capable of distributing its genes across the anthropogenically altered
landscape that now characterizes its Costa Rican dry forest habitat.
Keywords: allozymes, cpDNA, gene dispersal, genetic structure
Received 26 January 2004; revision received 19 May 2004; accepted 16 June 2004
Introduction
Plants accomplish gene dispersal during two independent
life cycle stages, via seeds and pollen. Successful pollen and
seed immigration and establishment into extant popu-
lations constitute gene flow events while seed dispersal
and establishment into vacant sites constitute colonization
( Levin 1981; Hamrick & Nason 1996). Because all natural
plant populations originate in this manner, colonization
is an important process shaping the genetic structure
of species ( Harper 1977; Slatkin 1977; Wade & McCauley
1988). Recognition of the two gene dispersal stages in
plants is critical to understanding the distribution of
genetic variation within and among populations (Levin
1981; Whitlock & McCauley 1990). Both pollen and
seeds disperse biparentally inherited nuclear genes while
maternally inherited gene movement depends exclusively
on seed dispersal. In most angiosperms, the nonrecombinant
chloroplast genome (cpDNA) is inherited maternally (Sears
1980; Corriveau & Coleman 1988; Mogensen 1996; Ennos
et al . 1999). By comparing the distribution of genetic markers
derived from nuclear (nDNA) and chloroplast genomes,
the relative influence of pollen and seed dispersal on gene
flow and genetic structure can be determined (Ennos 1994;
McCauley 1995). If pollen and seed dispersal rates differ,
cpDNA and nDNA should reveal different levels of spatial
genetic structure ( McCauley 1994; McCauley et al . 1996).
Thus, the distribution of genetic diversity for these two
distinct genomes can be used to infer the processes that
produce genetic structure. While an increasing number of
studies examine the relative contributions of pollen and
Correspondence: Dorset W. Trapnell. Fax: 706 542 1805; E-mail:
dorset@plantbio.uga.edu