© 2004 The MIT Electronic Journal of Middle East Studies Vol. 4, Spring
2004
Crossing Boundaries: New Perspectives on the Middle East
http://web.mit.edu/cis/www/mitejmes/
59
Navigating Modernization:
Bedouin Pastoralism and Climate Information in the Kingdom of
Saudi Arabia
Andrew Gardner and Timothy J. Finan
*
Introduction
*
There are four things a person cannot know: when you will die, where you will die,
how you will live your life as planned by Allah, and what rains will come.
These wise words were shared with us by an elderly Bedouin taking respite from
the hot midday sun in a small market town in northeastern Saudi Arabia. We were working
on a project funded by the Saudi Arabian government – a project with two distinct
purposes. First, using ethnographic methods, we had set out to describe the impact of the
Kuwaiti oilfield fires (set during the 1991 Gulf War) upon the rangelands of northern Saudi
Arabia and, by extension, upon the people and livelihoods that depend on this rangeland.
Second, we were to investigate ways that the Saudi Meteorological and Environmental
Protection Agency (MEPA) might better disseminate climate and weather information to
the Bedouin peoples of the northern deserts. The impacts of the oilfield fires have been
discussed elsewhere, and in this paper we explore the role of climate information in
contemporary Bedouin livelihoods.
1
Specifically, we wish to assess the need and value of
government-generated climate information as well as its potential impact upon the
livelihood strategies of the Bedouin peoples.
The sentiment conveyed by the elderly Bedouin above—that climate prediction
and climate forecasting are beyond the purview of the mortal—was a recurring theme in
our conversations in Bedouin encampments. We argue here, however, that this cultural
view is but one aspect of the complexities obscured by the notion of modernization. In
unpacking the various strands implicit in this notion, we seek to portray a highly variable set
of processes, in many ways unique to the Kingdom and its environs, and to contextualize
the interface between climate, environment, and the Bedouin nomads in these larger arenas.
Finally, we argue that numerous processes embedded within the notion of modernization
have reshaped nomad livelihoods in the Kingdom, minimizing the importance of climate
variability while simultaneously bringing a host of more pressing concerns to the fore.
*
Andrew Gardner is a PhD candidate in the department of Anthropology at the University of Arizona.
Timothy Finan is the director of the Bureau of Applied Research in Anthropology at the University of
Arizona.