REFUGEE INTEGRATION(S):
POLICY AND PRACTICE IN THE EUROPEAN UNION
Nando Sigona
Research Associate, Development and Forced Migration Research Unit,
Oxford Brookes University
INTRODUCTION
The present paper is based on the work I have been doing in the last few years
at the Development and Forced Migration Research Unit with Roger Zetter and
David Griffiths on three research projects on asylum and refugee policy of Euro-
pean Union Member States (EUMS).
The research projects focused in particular on asylum reception policy, poli-
cy and practice of refugee integration in the EU and on the impact of UK asylum
policy on refugee and asylum seeker organisations (Griffiths et al, 2005; Zetter et
al, 2002; Zetter et al, 2003; Zetter et al, 2005).
Here I will look in particular to the definition of integration which under-
pins EUMS policy and practice of refugee integration. The context of the discus-
sion is set by the ongoing process of harmonization of refugee and asylum policy
in the EU.
EU CONTEXT
If the road to hell is paved with good intentions, then the highway to community
harmonisation is littered with the debris of intergovernmental agreements (Blake,
2001: 95)
Some background info on this process, described as “one of tentative movement
from unilateral, to multilateral and finally communitarian legal instruments and
interventions” (Geddes, 2000: 107), will help to frame the discussion. Four main
phases can be pinpointed since it started in the late 60s:
• 1967-85, from the Naples Convention on mutual cooperation between cus-
tom authorities to the Treaty of Schengen (Single European Act) in 1986. A
number of so-called ad hoc groups were established in this period, the
most significant of whom was the TREVI
1
group. Established in 1976, it
dealt originally with mechanism of counterterrorism, but was expanded
to include issues such as police co-operation, drugs trafficking, border
policing. TREVI lacked a coherent organisational structure although it
acted as a prototype for later intergovernmental organisation prior to the
introduction of the Third Pillar of the EU in 1993 (Levy 1999:23).
• 1986-93, from Single European Act to Treaty of Maastricht (including the
Dublin Convention in 1990 and the Convention on the Crossing of External
borders in 1991). The Schengen Group was founded in 1985 by the core
Refugee Survey Quarterly, Vol. 24, Issue 4 © UNHCR 2005, all rights reserved
DOI:10.1093/rsq/hdi093
at Radcliffe Science Library, Bodleian Library on December 3, 2010 rsq.oxfordjournals.org Downloaded from