A Simulation Study of Exit Choice based on Effective Throughput of an Exit Area
in a Multi-Exit Evacuation Situation
Kashif Zia
Institute for Pervasive Computing
Johannes Kepler University
Linz, Austria
kashif.zia@researchstudio.at
Alois Ferscha
Institute for Pervasive Computing
Johannes Kepler University
Linz, Austria
ferscha@soft.uni-linz.ac.at
Abstract—To individuals evacuating, many multi-exit
environments do not allow visibility of all the exits due to line-
of-sight constraint. In addition, the environment can be dark
or smoky, not allowing visibility to even a single exit. In such a
situation, given that each individual in the crowd is
accompanied with a helping device globally connected with a
central server, a 'directional guidance' towards an optimal exit
is a real possibility. In this context, the 'occupant density'
around exits (within a static ‘exit area’) has been used in
conjunction with the corresponding distances to devise a
probabilistic strategy for optimal exit suggestion [1]. In this
paper, we related the exit area with the level of visibility of the
environment (the more the visibility, the more the exit area
and vice versa). In this way, a more realistic human-behavioral
model is implemented in which an individual viewing (seeing)
an exit would always direct towards that exit, irrespective of
the directional guidance provided. When an individual is not at
any of the exit areas (not viewing even a single exit), a
directional guidance is provided assuming that the individual
is adhering to it. Additionally we used the measure of 'effective
throughput' instead of occupant density, in conjunction with
the corresponding distances. Through simulation results, we
found a marked improvement in the evacuation time, when
effective throughput was modeled instead of occupant density.
Crowd Evacuation, Occupant Density, Crowd Simulation.
I. INTRODUCTION
Most crowd evacuation simulation systems are based on
human perceptions, particularly the sense of sight and
hearing. In a socio-technical system, some (or more)
individuals are equipped with at least one helping device,
thus providing a possibility of utilizing device-to-device
interaction for more efficient evacuation. Device-to-device
interaction is dependent on the communication range of the
devices and may result in the formation of different
communication zones, for example, local neighborhood,
clusters or groups (of varying sizes) and a global network.
Group dynamics, being a more complex and demanding
phenomena, involve more social behavioral aspects, thus
resulting in a deviation from a 'simple-to-start' socio-
technical system in which humans and devices have a one-
to-one relation. That is the reason, in this paper; we only
concentrate on the local neighborhood on one hand and a
global network on the other. These effectively two extremes
are more popularly categorized by the research community
as microscopic and macroscopic interaction.
Emerging crowd behavior at the macroscopic level
cannot be modeled without understanding of behavior of the
individuals at the microscopic level [2]. Alternatively,
modeling behavior at the local level accumulates to an
emerging behavior at the global level. Understanding the
dynamics of emerging behavior at the macroscopic level,
potentially suggests a continuous feedback to the individuals,
helping them readjust their local behavior to achieve the
desired patterns at the global level. More specifically, during
the crowd evacuation process, through the microscopic level
interaction, an individual (or a device holder) may know
about the local neighborhood and make a decision about the
next site to move to. If the macroscopic interaction is active
(suggestions provided by a server to the individual), the
decision about the next site would be under the influence of
the exit suggestion provided. A cumulative microscopic
activity in a region changes the global situation, and may
result in a slightly different suggestion to the same individual
for the next time.
The most prominent global goal of any evacuation
system is to increase the overall evacuation efficiency.
Mostly, the evacuation efficiency is a measure of evacuation
time i.e. the iterations required to evacuate all (or most of)
the population. Given that each of the individual is equipped
with a device, the environmental conditions (particularly its
location) can be communicated to a central server. As a
result of application of a macroscopic model at the server,
each individual (or device) in the population may be
provided with the optimal directional guidance. A directional
guidance provided in this way is indigenously dependent on
the macroscopic view of the environment based on the
phenomena of interest.
For the systems targeting the evacuation efficiency, the
phenomena of interest is related with the structure of the
environment. For example placement & level of threat(s),
damaged regions & presence of obstacles, geometry of
confinement area, population density and the visibility level.
Population density can be defined as a number of individuals
in a region. Traditionally, researchers have used Exit Area
(EA), i.e. area surrounded by an exit, as a more effective
region to measure the population density; the measure
known as Occupant Density (OD) at an exit. In this respect,
the main premise of the evacuation strategies is that an
individual potentially diverts from 'nearest' exit and selects
one of the remaining exits as its destination, considering the
OD at exits [3]. Mathematically this strategy was introduced
2009 13th IEEE/ACM International Symposium on Distributed Simulation and Real Time Applications
1550-6525/09 $26.00 © 2009 IEEE
DOI 10.1109/DS-RT.2009.13
235