How Not to Found a Field
547
How Not to Found a Field: New Evidence
on the Origins of Mass Communication
Research
By Karin Wahl-Jorgensen
This article offers new evidence on the beginnings of mass communication study
in the U.S., suggesting that the earliest communication programs were short-lived
interdisciplinary committees at the University of Chicago that were at the forefront
of an emerging field but died from lack of institutional support. Drawing on archi-
val research and interviews, the article suggests that communication study, as sepa-
rate from professional journalism training and the study of rhetoric, goes further
back than previously assumed. Finally, the article investigates why the Chicago
programs are unknown in our discipline’s history—and what this tells us about
academic institutions and mass communication research.
This article offers new evidence on the beginnings of mass communication study
in the U.S., suggesting that the earliest communication programs were short-lived
interdisciplinary committees at the University of Chicago that were at the forefront
of an emerging field, but died an early death from lack of institutional support.
Drawing on archival research and interviews,
1
the paper suggests that communi-
cation study, as separate from professional journalism training and the study of
rhetoric, goes further back than previously assumed. The article investigates why
the Chicago programs, which involved famous scholars widely credited as pio-
neers in communication research, are unknown in our discipline’s history, and
what that tells us about academic institutions in general and mass communication
research in particular.
The article argues that the resources committed to communication research
during World War II and in its aftermath legitimized the field. In addition, the
problems of communication, public opinion, and democracy that occupied the
Karin Wahl-Jorgensen (PhD, Stanford University) is a lecturer at Cardiff University. Correspondence
should be directed to the author at JOMEC, Cardiff University, Bute Bldg., King Edward VII Ave.,
Cardiff, CF10 3NB, Wales, UK. The author thanks Ted Glasser for his help and encouragement.
Copyright © 2004 International Communication Association
1
The author would like to thank John Richardson, Andrew Abbott, and Martin Bulmer for their support
and advice, and the staff at the Special Archives at the University of Chicago’s Regenstein Library for
their help.