SETC2009
2009-32-0026 / 20097026
Experimental Investigation of Performance and Emissions of
a Sequential Port Injection Compressed Natural Gas
Converted Engine
How Heoy Geok, Taib Iskandar Mohamad, Shahrir Abdullah, Yusoff Ali and
Azhari Shamsudeen
Department of Mechanical and Materials Engineering, National University of Malaysia
Copyright © 2009 SAE Japan and Copyright © 2009 SAE International
ABSTRACT
A single cylinder port injection gasoline engine was
converted to a bi-fuel gasoline-compressed natural gas
operation. The engine was run at wide open throttle
and speeds ranging from 1500 to 5000 rpm. Cylinder
pressure and air-fuel flow rate were recorded to
calculate the indicated performance. Results show
CNG operation yields higher FCE and lower ISFC.
However, the indicated power, indicated torque, IMEP
and volumetric efficiency of CNG were reduced due to
lower charge density and slower flame speed. In terms
of exhaust emissions, CNG shows significantly lower
emission of HC, CO
2
and CO. The NO
x
emission
however shows mixed behavior.
INTRODUCTION
The use of alternative fuels in automotive engines has
gained more attentions due to the increased
conventional fuel prices and enforcement of stringent
emission limits. Various alternative fuels suited for
spark ignition (SI) engines have been studied
extensively and utilized in vehicles. Promising results
have been obtained from the fuel economy and
exhaust emissions points of view [1-3]. These fuels
can be categorized into synthetic gasoline, alcohols
and gaseous fuels [4, 5]. Among all, natural gas is
probably the most widely studied and used alternative
fuel due to its worldwide availability and also its
adaptability to the gasoline and diesel engines. Natural
gas-fuelled engine has the potential for obtaining
higher thermal efficiency, less knocking tendency and
low CO
2
exhaust emissions due to its lower carbon-to-
hydrogen ratio and higher octane value which allows
higher compression ratio operation compared to those
of gasoline [6-8].
Nowadays, most natural gas-fuelled engines
are converted from gasoline or diesel engine. Only
small fractions are developed for dedicated
compressed natural gas (CNG) operation. The
converted engine uses the built-in fuel system (i.e.
carburettor or port injection) to deliver fuel to the
cylinder. These result in some drawbacks, mainly
reduced power and limited upper speed, which are due
to lower charge inhaled energy (due to reduced
volumetric efficiency) and slower natural gas flame
speed respectively [9]. It is reported that power,
volume efficiency and brake mean effective pressure
were reduced significantly when converting port
injection engine from gasoline to natural gas [10-12].
One method to overcome the problem is to directly
inject natural gas into the combustion chamber. Direct
injection (DI) can increase the absolute heating value
of the cylinder charge and enhance turbulence
intensity for better mixing prior to ignition [13].
Combustion efficiency is increased which produces
better torque and power, reduces pumping and heat
losses and allows better control of the air fuel ratio
(AFR) [14-16]. Besides, DI of natural gas can maintain
the smoke free operation of SI engines and produce
lower NO
x
emissions compared to the unthrottled
diesel engines [17]. However, the development of a DI
engine is costly and technically difficult. This is due to
the needs for development of a new cylinder head to
acclimate with direct fuel injector and also involves
tedious calibration of the engine control system [18].
Sequential port or manifold fuel injection of
natural gas can offer an immediate solution for the
drawbacks of CNG converted engine. In this system,
natural gas is injected by an injector at the intake
manifold just before the opening of intake valve. As a
result, better control of mixture formation and response
to changing speed can be achieved by using
programmable electronic control unit (ECU). Thus, it
provides the opportunity to reduce the negative effects
on the performance compared to carburettor-type CNG
fuel system. This paper discusses the results obtained
from experimental investigation of the sequential
port/manifold injection natural gas engine with respect
to performance, combustion characteristics and
exhaust emissions.
EXPERIMENTAL SETUP AND PROCEDURES
A single cylinder port injection gasoline engine was
converted to a CNG-gasoline bi-fuel sequential port
fuel injection and a programmable ECU was installed
to control the CNG operation. The engine can be
operated either with gasoline or CNG by switching