Prevalence of Risk Factors for Hepatitis C Virus in HIV-Infected
and HIV/Hepatitis C Virus-Coinfected Patients
SRIGAYATRI BOLLEPALLI, MD,* KATHLEEN MATHIESON, PHD,* CURT BAY, PHD,* AMY HILLIER, PAC,*
JOHN POST, MD,* DAVID H. VAN THIEL, MD,† AND ABDUL NADIR, MD*
Methods: A sample of patients with HIV completed a questionnaire
identifying their demographic characteristics and risk factors for hep-
atitis C virus (HCV). A chart review was conducted to confirm the
information obtained using the questionnaire. Risk factors associated
with coinfection status at level of 0.1 in univariate analysis were
entered into a multivariate Cox regression model.
Results: Of the 242 HIV-positive patients analyzed, 168 were HIV-
infected and 74 were HIV/HCV-coinfected. Risk factors that were
significantly different between HIV-monoinfected and HIV/HCV-coin-
fected subjects included intravenous drug use, snorting drugs, sharing
razors or toothbrushes, being in prison, the presence of one or more
tattoos, sex for money or drugs, sex with an intravenous drug user and
man who has sex with men. In a multivariate regression model, only
intravenous drug use remained as a significant risk factor/predictor of
HCV/HIV coinfection. A subanalysis identified risk factors more prev-
alent among coinfected men who have sex with men, including intra-
venous drug use, sharing razors/toothbrushes, tattoos, sex for money
or drugs, sex with an intravenous drug user, and a history of having 11
or more sexual partners. A history of having had a sexually transmit-
ted disease and 11 or more sex partners was more prevalent among
HIV-monoinfected men who have sex with men.
Conclusions: HIV/HCV coinfection was associated with intrave-
nous drug use but not with sexual risk factors.
SEXUAL TRANSMISSION OF HEPATITIS C virus (HCV) has
remained a subject of controversy. The prevalence of HCV is
much higher in HIV-infected individuals in contrast to the preva-
lence of HIV in HCV-infected individuals. These observations can
be explained in part as a result of a predominant role for sexual
transmission of HIV and a parenteral route for HCV transmission.
1
Recently, outbreaks of acute HCV have been reported in highly
promiscuous men who have sex with men (MSM) in Europe.
Investigators from a Swiss cohort reported 22 episodes of acute
HCV in 14 homosexual and 8 heterosexual men (P 0.001) who
had previously tested negative for HCV. In Paris, 10 of 12 cases of
genotype 4D HCV infection having a closely related HCV genome
were identified in homosexual MSM.
2–5
One study reported a higher
prevalence of HCV among MSM as compared with a group of blood
donors. A multivariate analysis showed that this finding could be
accounted for by a history of intravenous drug use (IVDU).
6
Although
these reports are tantalizing, sequence homology of HCV clones has
its own limitations and does not definitively confirm transmission of
HCV from one individual to another.
7
In contrast to these recent reports, many epidemiologic studies
have failed to show an association between sexual risk factors and
HCV infection. Heterosexual monogamous couples who have been
followed prospectively have failed to support sexual transmission
of HCV.
8
In addition, the prevalence of HCV among MSM has not
been found to be different from that of heterosexual men despite
the fact that MSM have higher rates of sexually transmitted dis-
eases and more numerous sexual partners.
9
Finally, a prospective
cohort study of MSM (40.3% having 50 casual partners) docu-
mented a strong association between HCV infection and IVDU,
but not between HCV and sexual orientation.
10
The epidemiologic surveys used in many studies presume that
the information obtained from a subject using a questionnaire is
accurate. Specifically for HCV transmission, nondisclosure of IVDU
by study participants would certainly invalidate the results of any such
survey.
11
To achieve meaningful data from an epidemiologic survey
regarding HCV transmission, all recognized risk factors for HCV
transmission (e.g., tattoos, snorting nasal cocaine, birth in underde-
veloped countries, hemodialysis, sharing of household items, being in
prison, and sexual factors) must be considered.
12–14
The current study
sought to identify sexual and other risk factors that distinguish be-
tween HIV-monoinfected and HCV/HIV-coinfected individuals.
Methods
This was a cross-sectional study conducted from January 28,
2005, to May 13, 2005. Patients were selected by convenience
sampling from 2 urban clinics catering specifically to patients who
are HIV-infected and those with liver disease in Phoenix, Arizona.
A trained physician researcher attended the HIV and liver disease
clinics 3 times a week throughout the study period, approached
potential subjects in the waiting room at each location, and told
prospective subjects the study was designed to identify risk factors
for HCV transmission in an HIV-infected population. Each poten-
tial subject was told that their involvement in the study would
consist of the completion of a self-administered survey that would
take 5 to 10 minutes and that the researchers would have access to
their medical records, but their personal information would be kept
confidential. A total of 360 patients were approached, and 316
(88%) agreed to participate.
The questionnaires were administered in both English and Span-
ish depending on the subject’s preference and included questions
Correspondence: Abdul Nadir, MD, 2601 E. Roosevelt Street, Phoenix,
AZ 85008. E-mail: anadir786@aol.com.
Received for publication March 26, 2006, and accepted July 25, 2006.
From *Maricopa Medical Center (MMC) Phoenix, Arizona; and †St.
Luke’s Hospital, Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Sexually Transmitted Diseases, June 2007, Vol. 34, No. 6, p.367–370
DOI: 10.1097/01.olq.0000240295.35457.b1
Copyright © 2007, American Sexually Transmitted Diseases Association
All rights reserved.
367