643
The Impact of Unfair Treatment on
Depressive Mood: The Moderating Role of
Self-Esteem Level and Self-Esteem Instability
Laurenz L. Meier
Norbert K. Semmer
Jörg Hupfeld
University of Bern, Switzerland
anxiety and depression (e.g., Niedhammer, David, &
Degioanni, 2006; Schulz et al. 2006), and daily hassles
are related to negative affect, low self-esteem, and
depression on a daily level (e.g., Bolger, DeLongis, Kessler,
& Schilling, 1989; Nezlek & Plesko, 2001, 2003; Zeigler-
Hill & Showers, 2007). Chronic stressors and negative
events vary in the degree of their severity. Events involving
interpersonal rejection may be especially aversive because
they undermine the fundamental need to belong to
significant groups and to maintain good interpersonal
relationships (Baumeister & Leary, 1995). Previous
research has shown that rejection is likely to compromise
people’s well-being (see Leary, 2001; Williams, 2007).
Interpersonal rejection can take many forms and occurs
in different social contexts, such as rejection by a romantic
partner, bullying at school, exclusion from a sport club,
or unfair treatment at the workplace.
Unfair treatment at the workplace can have different
faces. Generally, researchers have identified three types
of (un)fairness (see Colquitt, Greenberg, & Zapata-
Phelan, 2005): first, fairness of outcomes (distributive
fairness); second, fairness of procedures used for
allocation decisions (procedural fairness); and third,
fairness of interpersonal treatment during procedures
Authors’ Note: Laurenz L. Meier and Norbert K. Semmer are affili-
ated with the Swiss Centre for Affective Sciences. We thank Ulrich
Orth, Sven Gross, Fabienne T. Amstad, Martial Berset, Viviane Gisler,
and Colm O’Mahony for their helpful comments on an earlier version
of this article and Markus Hausammann, Christian Rohr, and David
Schönenberger for their help during data collection. Correspondence
concerning this article should be addressed to Laurenz L. Meier,
Department of Psychology, University of Bern, Muesmattstrasse 45,
CH-3000 Bern 9, Switzerland; e-mail: laurenz.meier@psy.unibe.ch.
PSPB, Vol. 35 No. 5, May 2009 643-655
DOI: 10.1177/0146167208331337
© 2009 by the Society for Personality and Social Psychology, Inc.
This research examines the moderating roles of self-es-
teem level and self-esteem instability in the relationship
between perceived unfair treatment and depressive
mood. Based on the assumption that unfairness is a
threat to one’s social standing and self-esteem, the
authors proposed that individuals with highly fragile
self-esteem (i.e., the combination of unstable and high
self-esteem) react more strongly when experiencing
unfair treatment. This hypothesis was tested in a real-
world setting using cross-sectional and diary data of
101 employees. As expected, unfair treatment was
related to depressive mood among individuals with
unstable high self-esteem but not among individuals
with stable high self-esteem. This pattern of results held
for both cross-sectional and diary data. In contrast,
unfairness was not related to depressive mood among
individuals with unstable low self-esteem.
Keywords: self-esteem; self-esteem instability; fairness; depres-
sive mood
R
esearch suggests that people are highly concerned
about how fairly they are treated by others and
that they react with impaired well-being to perceived
unfairness (Folger & Cropanzano, 1998). However,
individuals differ in the degree to which they are reac-
tive to unfair events (De Cremer, 2002a). This study
focuses on individual differences by examining the mod-
erating effects of self-esteem level and instability.
Unfair treatment can be regarded as a stressor.
Stressors, both in terms of chronic conditions and in
terms of negative daily events, affect psychological
adjustment on a chronic level as well as on a daily level.
For example, enduring stressors like the experience of
workplace bullying and discrimination are related to