J. Child Psyc/ul. PsycUa Vol. 26, No. 5, pp. 811-824. 1985. 0021-9630/85 13.00 + 0.00
Printed in Great Britain Pergamon Press Ltd.
© 1985 Association for Child Psychology and Psychiatry.
THE DEVELOPMENT OF CONCEPTS OF SIMULTANEITY IN
CHILDREN'S UNDERSTANDING OF EMOTIONS
NADJA REISSLAND
Department of Experimental Psychology, University of Oxford
Abstract—The development of children's understanding of simultaneously occurring emotions was
investigated. A developmental progression was found in their giving examples of ambivalent situations
(e.g. characterised by both happiness and anger); and in their descriptions of situations. The youngest
children (mean age = 5.8) gave as examples of ambivalence two unrelated events associated with
different emotions. At the next stage children (mean age « 7.0) were able to connect sequentially two
events. At a third stage (mean age - 10.1) the children were able to conceive of situations in which
two emotions of opposite valence occurred simultaneously.
Keywords: Simultaneity, ambivalence, emotions, cognition
INTRODUCTION
RECENT research among developmental psychologists has focused on children's
understanding of the relation between different emotions. Harter (1979) has investi-
gated the relation between being happy and being 'mad', 'sad', and scared. Selman
(1980) questioned children concerning their knowledge of the conflict between the
good feeling of friendship and the bad feeling of an event or action which troubled
that friendship. Carroll (1981), Tharinger (1981), Nannis (1983) and Harris (in press)
have examined children's understanding of situations characterised by happiness
and sadness.
Common to much of this research has been the observation that at a certain age
children are able to comprehend ambivalent situations, that is to say, situations
characterised by simultaneously occurring emotions of opposite valence. The ability
to comprehend such situations implies that the children have a concept of simultaneity.
The development of this concept with reference to emotions has been recently
investigated by Harter and Buddin (1983) and by Harris (in press). Harter and
Buddin elicted from children examples of situations, characterised by two different
emotions and they analysed these examples with reference to the valence of each
emotion and the person, or 'target', to whom the emotion was directed. A develop-
mental progression was found in which the children were first able to relate two
simultaneously occurring emotions of the same valence and target (mean ages = 6.5
years) and then two emotions of the same valence but different target (mean
age = 8.0 years). It was not until 10.5 years of age that the subjects were able to
Requests for reprints to: Nadja Reissland, Department of Experimental Psychology, South Parks
Road, Oxford, U.K.
Accepted manuscript received 12 October 1984
811