[JNES 71 no. 2 (2012)] © 2012 by The University of Chicago. All rights reserved. 022–2968–2012/7102–005 $10.00.
275
The Grammar of the Neo-Babylonian
Assertory Oath
BRUCE WELLS (Saint Joseph’s University), CORNELIA WUNSCH (University of London), and
F. RACHEL MAGDALENE (Universität Leipzig)
Introduction
The purpose of this article is to review grammatical
constructions that can function as assertory oaths.
1
Previously, scholars have observed that oaths con-
structed with a verb in the preterite tense functioned as
negative assertory oaths (oaths of denial).
2
The article
will argue that evidence exists to question whether
negative assertory oaths made use of verbs only in
1
Research for this article has been funded in large measure by
the U.S. National Endowment for the Humanities and its award
of a Collaborative Research Grant for the authors’ project, “Neo-
Babylonian Trial Procedure.” Any views, indings, conclusions, or
recommendations expressed in this publication are those of the au-
thors alone and do not necessarily represent those of the National
Endowment for the Humanities. The abbreviations herein follow
those of the most recent volume (U/W) of the Assyrian Dictionary
of the Oriental Institute of the University of Chicago (CAD; Chicago,
2010). All translations of ancient texts, unless otherwise noted, are
those of the authors. We thank Małgorzata Sandowicz and our peer
reviewers for their insights on an earlier draft of this article. Of
course, all remaining errors are the authors’ alone.
2
It is beyond the scope of this article to enter the debate be-
tween “tense” and “aspect” for describing categories such as pres-
ent, preterite, and perfect. We follow Michael Streck’s view that
“das spB Verbalsystem grundlegend ein relatives Tempussystem
mit enger Ainität zu einem Apektsystem [sic] darstellt” (Zahl und
Zeit: Grammatik der Numeralia und des Verbalsystems im Spätbaby-
lonischen [Groningen, 1995], 245).
the preterite form. At least two Neo-Babylonian legal
and administrative texts suggest that scribes used the
perfect tense on occasion.
Verb Tense in the Oath
It is well known that assertory oaths in Neo-Babylo-
nian legal texts are formulated as conditional state-
ments in which an apodosis is left unstated.
3
For
instance, a person might swear, “If I stole the donkey,
. . . . ” The unstated apodosis would be understood
by the oath-taker and bystanders as well to be “may
I be cursed,” “may the gods punish me,” or the like.
4
3
See, e.g., GAG, §185a, j–k; and Johannes Hackl, Der subordi-
nierte Satz in den spätbabylonischen Briefen, Alter Orient und Altes
Testament 41 (Münster, 2007), 72–73.
4
Assertory oaths in earlier periods also typically had unstated
apodoses; see, in general, Sophie Lafont, “La procédure par ser-
ment au Proche-Orient ancien,” in Jurer et maudire: pratiques poli-
tiques et usages juridiques du serment dans le Proche-Orient ancien,
ed. Sophie Lafont (Paris, 1997). There are only a few oaths that
include them. See, e.g., EA 209, lines 13–16: “If I have not pro-
tected your cities, may the gods who are with you strike my head”
(Blaine Conklin, Oath Formulas in Biblical Hebrew [Winona Lake,
IN, 2011], 87); and the prayer in UET 6 402, which contains an
assertory oath that includes the curses of leprosy, poverty, and child-
lessness. The assertory oath was just one of a few procedures that
appealed to the gods for resolution of the legal dispute at issue. For