Copyright © 2011, Locke Science Publishing Company, Inc.
Chicago, IL, USA All Rights Reserved
Journal of Architectural and Planning Research
28:4 (Winter, 2011) 336
DESIGNING MOSQUES FOR SECULAR
CONGREGATIONS: TRANSFORMATIONS OF THE
MOSQUE AS A SOCIAL SPACE IN TURKEY
Serpil Özaloglu
Meltem Ö. Gürel
This study examines contemporary meanings and uses of the mosque in Turkey by arguing that
productive architectural plans require understanding both the socio-historical development of
the mosque and the socio-political transformations that have led to the mosque’s current
position in society. Mosque space is conceptualized as a physical environment that cultivates
the formation and transformation of individual, social, and collective memories. The study
questions whether the mosque still exhibits the qualities of a social space and whether new and
innovative mosque designs reflect — programmatically, architecturally, and spatially —
transformations related to their current uses and social meanings. These questions are explored
through interviews, two questionnaires, and a worksheet, all of which involve a case study of
Dogramacizade Mosque in Ankara. On one hand, the findings underscore the changing
relationship between Muslim women and mosque space as a result of the transformation of
congregations into citizens of a contemporary secular nation and suggest that spatial designs of
mosques should take present-day behaviors and practices into consideration rather than
ignoring this social aspect through which transformations occur. On the other hand, the
collective memory of congregation members resists changing the allocation of prayer halls in
the mosque. Members are in favor of continuing the traditional layout of separated spaces based
on gender differences. The resistance implies that collective memory changes much slower than
behaviors or lifestyles in terms of gender issues. Additionally, parallel to the findings,
modernization of the mosque brings forth the idea of resurrecting the mosque’s historical form as
a social complex that fundamentally conflicts with secularity.
320211_TXT_JOURNAL.indd 72 2/21/12 12:14 AM