A WOZ Environment for Studying Mutual Adaptive Behaviors in
Gesture-based Human-robot Interaction
Yong XU, Shinpei TAKEDA and Toyoaki NISHIDA
Graduate School of Informatics, Kyoto University
Yoshida-Honmachi, Sakyo-ku, Kyoto
606-8501, Japan
{xuyong, takeda}@ii.ist.i.kyoto-u.ac.jp, nishida@i.kyoto-u.ac.jp
Abstract
Mutual adaptation is considered to be one of the key
issues in realizing a human robot interaction (HRI)
system. In order to develop a mutually adaptive
interactive robot system, the authors adopt a
bootstrapping approach comprising three stages: a
human-human WOZ (Wizard of OZ) experiment, a human-
robot WOZ experiment, and a human-adaptive robot
experiment. This paper will focus on the second stage
where the authors developed a human-robot WOZ
experimental environment and conducted an experiment
to evaluate its effectiveness. The primary results
suggested the following: the WOZ environment can
function well; the operator’s view mode can be
considered as a relatively intuitive operational mode for
a human WOZ operator; and the realtime video image of
the robot’s movement is necessary for the WOZ operator
when he/she operates the robot while simultaneously
watching the gestural instructions of the instructor.
Some adaptive behaviors are observed as well. In
addition, the primary results also suggested that the
environment can be easily utilized with minor
modifications to build a human-adaptive robot
experiment.
Introduction
In recent years, the scope of robotics has extended well
beyond industrial applications into several other fields
including education, entertainment, and household
appliances. In the near future, household robots and service
robots are likely to become full-fledged family members.
For example, as of May 2006, more than 2 million iRobot
Roomba vacuuming robots have been sold worldwide
(IROBOT 2007). The capacity of robot-environment-
interaction is important for autonomous robots to
accomplish simple tasks by interacting with the
environment; however, the capacity of human-robot-
interaction (HRI) for household or service robots such as
nursing-care robots, guide robots, or waiter robots to
Copyright © 2007, Association for the Advancement of Artificial
Intelligence (www.aaai.org). All rights reserved.
perform cooperative tasks becomes more important. In
order to create such robots, aspects such as “easy to use”
or “easy to understand” must be emphasized so that non-
specialists can easily understand and instruct such robots.
Traditional human-computer interfaces may be
inappropriate for this purpose since non-specialist users
may experience difficulties in interacting with a robot using
such interfaces. These interfaces may also cause
unnecessary physical and/or mental stress in human users
since they must adjust their behavior to the system.
In order to realize a powerful interactive human-robot
interface, the authors argue that mutual adaptation is a key
feature to realize a user-friendly interactive human-robot
interface. Mutual adaptation is a phenomenon where two
interacting partners adapt to each other during their
interaction. In the case of HRI, robots can typically adapt
only to some specific people and learn their behaviors. In
contrast, the authors attempt to realize a mutually adaptive
robot that can not only adapt to any person but also utilize
humans’ adaptability to dynamically establish
communication protocols. In other words, the same
instruction used by different people may contain different
meanings, or different reactions are expected from the robot.
In particular, when attempting to develop an interactive
robot that can gradually adapt to human instructions
through nonverbal communication, it is necessary to
express the internal states of the robot such that mutual
adaptation can occur.
This research adopts a bootstrapping approach that
comprises three stages: a human-human WOZ (Wizard-of-
Oz) experiment, a human-robot WOZ experiment, and a
human-adaptive robot experiment. Instead of directly going
to the third stage, we first make detailed observations of
how people adapt to each other and how people improve
the protocols for interacting with robots since it appears to
be difficult to design a mutually adaptive robot system
directly without any previous knowledge about mutually
adaptive behavior. A WOZ experiment is a frequently used
method in which participants interact with a system that is
assumed to function autonomously. In fact, the system is
usually fully or partially operated by a human operator.
The goal of such experiments is to observe the behavior of
40