Theory Into Practice, 49:250–257, 2010
Copyright © The College of Education and Human Ecology, The Ohio State University
ISSN: 0040-5841 print/1543-0421 online
DOI: 10.1080/00405841.2010.510447
Alfredo J. Artiles
Aydin Bal
Kathleen A. King Thorius
Back to the Future:
A Critique of Response to
Intervention’s Social Justice Views
The emergence of Response to Intervention (RTI)
anticipates a different future for all students,
particularly learners from racial minority back-
grounds and students with disabilities. RTI is
being widely adopted in school districts as a
viable alternative to enhance learning oppor-
tunities; hence, some education scholars ar-
gue it promises a much-needed response to
longstanding injustices for underserved students.
Alfredo Artiles is a professor of Special Education
and Transborder Chicana/o Latina/o Studies, Arizona
State University; Aydin Bal is an assistant professor
of Rehabilitation Psychology and Special Education at
University of Wisconsin, Madison; Kathleen A. King
Thorius is an assistant professor of Teacher Education/
Special Education at Indiana University–Indianapolis.
Correspondence should be addressed to Professor
Alfredo Artiles, Special Education and Transborder
Chicana/o Latina/o Studies, Arizona State University,
P.O. Box 2011, Farmer Ed Bldg. ED 244B, Tempe,
AZ 85287-2011. E-mail: alfredo.artiles@asu.edu
RTI aims to address injustices in the distri-
bution of educational opportunities and recog-
nition of underserved groups of students. The
authors identify the underlying views of social
justice that permeate RTI and conclude with a
closer look at RTI’s justice claims embedded
in some implementation procedures. They pro-
pose it is important to revisit the anticipated
future promised by RTI through the refinement
of the social justice perspectives used in this
literature.
I
N 1978, EDWIN MARTIN, then Deputy Com-
missioner in the Bureau of Education for
the Handicapped, reminisced about the struggles
over creating and passing P.L. 94-142. He ex-
plained how individuals and organizations such
as the Council for Exceptional Children ap-
250
Downloaded By: [Artiles, Alfred J] At: 14:32 9 October 2010