Spiral scanning: An alternative to conventional raster scanning in
high-speed Scanning Probe Microscopes
I. A. Mahmood and S. O. R. Moheimani
Abstract— A spiral scanning method for high-speed Atomic
Force Microscopy (AFM) is described in this paper. In this
method, the sample is scanned in a spiral pattern instead of
the conventional raster pattern. A spiral scan can be produced
by applying single frequency cosine and sine signals with slowly
varying amplitudes to the x axis and y axis of an AFM scanner
respectively. The use of the single tone input signals allows the
scanner to move at high speeds without exciting the mechanical
resonance of the device and with relatively small control efforts.
These scan methods can be incorporated into most modern
AFMs with minimal effort since they can be implemented in
software using the existing hardware. Experimental results ob-
tained by implementing this scanning method on a commercial
AFM indicate that the obtained images are of a good quality
and the profile of the calibration grating is well captured up
to scan frequency of 120 Hz with a scanner where the first
resonance frequency is 580 Hz.
I. I NTRODUCTION
AFM was invented by Binnig et al. in 1986 [1] based
on their design of the scanning tunneling microscopy (STM)
[2], [3]. The main use of AFM is for imaging sample surface
topography with a very high precision down to the atomic
scale. Since its invention, it has emerged as a standard tool
in nanotechnology research. This is because it can be used
on any sample surfaces and in any environment including
air, various gases, vacuum and fluid. Additionally, the AFM
can also operate at high and low temperature. The basic
components of the AFM include a micro-cantilever with a
sharp tip on the free end, a scanner and a laser-photodetector
sensor. During operation, the tip of the micro-cantilever is
brought very close to the sample surface at a distance of the
order of a few nanometers, or less. At such a distance, the
interactive forces that exist between the tip and the sample
surface change the deflections of the micro-cantilever. These
changes in the micro-cantilever are measured using the laser-
photodetector sensor [4]. AFM images can be generated by
scanning the tip at a constant height over the area of inter-
est on the sample surface. During scan, the measurements
from the photodetector will vary according to the sample
topographic features. These measurements are recorded and
plotted as a function of the scanner’s lateral positions to
produce an AFM image of the sample surface. Acquisition
of the AFM image in this manner is called constant-height
mode.
Today, the majority of commercially available AFMs use
raster scans to image a sample’s surface. A raster scan is
I. A. Mahmood and S. O. R. Moheimani are with School of Electrical En-
gineering and Computer Science, The University of Newcastle, Callaghan,
NSW 2308, Australia. Reza.Moheimani@newcastle.edu.au
performed by moving the scanner along the x axis (fast-
axis) in forward and reversed directions (line scan), and then
moving the piezoelectric tube along the y axis (slow-axis) in
a small step to reach the next line scan. This movement
is attained by applying a triangular wave signal to the x
axis and a slowly increasing staircase signal to the y axis
of the scanner. In order to scan the sample at high speed,
a high frequency triangular waveform needs to be used. A
drawback of a triangular waveform is that it contains all odd
harmonics of the fundamental frequency whose amplitudes
attenuate as 1/n
2
, with n being the harmonic number [5].
If a fast triangular waveform is applied to the scanner, the
harmonics will inevitably excite the mechanical resonance
of the scanner. Consequently, this causes the scanner to
vibrate and trace a distorted triangular waveform along the x
axis which can significantly distort the generated image. To
avoid this complication, the scanning speed of AFMs is often
limited to about 10 - 100 times lower then the scanner’s first
resonance frequency [6].
Recently, there has been significant interest in utilizing
feedback control to deal with resonant nature of AFM
nanopositioners, e. g. see [7] for an exhaustive overview of
the literature, and [8], [9], [10], [11], [12], [13] for further
related results. In this approach, a feedback controller is
used to flatten the frequency response of the scanner, thus
allowing for faster scans. However, as the scan frequency is
increased closer to the mechanical bandwidth of the scanner
in order to realize high-speed AFM, the positioning precision
of the scanner deteriorate considerably. The closed-loop
tracking of the triangular waveform typically results in the
corners of these waveform to be rounded off and distorted.
This is mainly due to the presence of the high frequency
harmonics that are outside of the bandwidth of the closed-
loop system. Consequently, AFM images generated at high
speeds often demonstrate significant distortions especially
around the edges of the images.
It should be noted that, recently a few prototype laboratory
AFMs have been developed that are capable of imaging a
sample at, or close to, video-rates, [14], [15], [16], [17]. Such
functionality is particularly important for observing dynamic
processes of nanoscale biological specimens, e.g. cells and
biopolymers. In order to achieve video rates, using a raster
scanned AFM; the scan frequency has to be very high, close
to 5 kHz or higher. However to attain such a scan frequency
calls for complicated scanner design in order to make the
scanner’s first resonance frequency much higher than the
scan frequency. Additionally, high scanner’s first resonance
frequency also implies low scan range [18].
2010 American Control Conference
Marriott Waterfront, Baltimore, MD, USA
June 30-July 02, 2010
FrB08.4
978-1-4244-7425-7/10/$26.00 ©2010 AACC 5757