‘I dislike politicians and homosexuals’:
Language and homophobia in
contemporary France
Denis M. Provencher
Abstract
In this essay, I examine the pragmatic and social semiotic aspects of recent hate
speech against French politicians and homosexuals. In part one I analyse the
discourse surrounding the 2002 stabbing of Paris mayor Bertrand Delanoë in which
his assailant Azedine Berkane expressed dislike for ‘politicians and homosexuals’.
he French media and authorities generally did not frame this as a ‘homophobic
act’ and ignored any potentially logical association between the two terms (i.e.
‘politicians’ and ‘homosexuals’). In order to better understand his statement, I
examine Berkane’s act in relation to what other spectators and participants said
about it both immediately following the event and sometime after its occurrence.
In part two of the essay, I link Berkane’s homophobic statement to a broader French
semiotic system and set of textual practices including several examples of hate speech
that occurred during an attack on Bègles mayor Noël Mamère. I analyse represen-
tative examples of hate speech received by Mamère when he performed the irst and
only gay marriage in France in 2004. By examining examples of hate speech from
the ‘Mamère Afair’, it is possible to gain a better understanding of the ideological
underpinnings of Berkane’s seemingly illogical statement in the ‘Delanoë Afair’.
KEYWORDS: ANTI-SEMITISM; CITIZENSHIP; BERTRAND DELANOë; FRANCE; HETERONORMATIVITY;
HOMOPHOBIA; MASCULINITY; NOëL MAMèRE; POLITICIANS; REPUBLICANISM
Gender
and
Language
G&L (PRINT) ISSN 1747–6321
G&L (ONLINE) ISSN 1747–633X
Article
Affiliation
University of Maryland Baltimore County, USA
email: provench@umbc.edu
G&L VOL 4.2 2010 287–321
© 2011, EQUINOX PUBLISHING
doi: 10.1558/genl.v4i2.287
www.equinoxpub.com