1
BHS Third International Symposium, Managing Consequences of a Changing Global Environment, Newcastle 2010
© British Hydrological Society
Disturbance of gravel substrates by signal crayish (Pacifastacus
leniusculus)
Matthew F. Johnson, Stephen P. Rice and Ian Reid
Department of Geography, Loughborough University,UK
Email: M.F.Johnson@lboro.ac.uk
Abstract
This paper focuses on signal crayish, an internationally widespread invasive species, and their
impacts on luvial gravel substrates. In a series of laboratory lume experiments, it was found
that crayish signiicantly altered the microtopography of substrates by constructing shallow pits
within which they sheltered and mounding excavated material into ridges. Crayish also altered
the fabric of gravel substrates by brushing past grains when walking, altering grain geometry. This
had a signiicant impact on the structural characteristics of water-worked gravels, resulting in a
reduction in imbrication of surface grains. The structural and topographic alterations to substrates
exposed to crayish had a highly signiicant impact on gravel stability. Nearly twice as many grains
were mobilised from substrates disturbed by crayish than from control surfaces which were not
exposed to crayish. This was mainly due to increased grain protrusion associated with crayish
constructing pits and mounds on the substrate surface. The results of this study suggest that signal
crayish could oppose the consolidation and structuring of gravel substrates in rivers, resulting in
a signiicant alteration in substrate stability during subsequent high low events.
Introduction
The reworking of substrates by organisms is considered
a fundamental process operating in marine and terrestrial
environments (Murry et al., 2002; Gabet et al., 2003) but has
been less studied in gravel-bed rivers with a few noticeable
exceptions, including the reworking of gravels by spawning
salmonid ish (e.g. Gottesfeld et al., 2004; Hassan et al.,
2008). The relative coarseness of the substrate and the high
energy low environment of gravel-bed rivers may result
in organisms being less effective geomorphic agents than
in other environments. However, it is known that relatively
small alterations to the geometry of surface grains in rivers
can have a substantial impact on their entrainment. For
instance, the orientation and pivot angle of grains will
determine the cross-sectional area exposed to the low and the
ease with which one grain will roll over a downstream grain
(Li and Komar, 1986; Kirchner et al., 1990; Carling et al.,
1992).
Grains which protrude high into the low will also
undergo greater low forces than those sheltering close to the
bed or behind coarser grains (Fenton and Abbott, 1977). The
continuous, unidirectional low in rivers alters the location
and geometry of surface grains by moving vulnerable grains
into less vulnerable positions. As a result, water-worked
substrates are more stable than loose, random arrangements
of gravel. Typical characteristics of water-working are cluster
bedforms and imbrication where grains overlap, locking
together and imparting stability to multiple grains (Reid
and Hassan, 1992). If the activity of organisms in luvial
environments can alter the surface structure of substrates
then this may have signiicant implications for the stability
of surface grains. This could result in increased transport of
bedload and suspended load which would have a substantial
impact on the geomorphology of the reach and could also
result in the mobilisation of contaminates. Destabilising the
substrate surface would also have signiicant implications on
benthic organisms which reside on the bed. In this paper we
focus on signal crayish (Pacifastacus leniusculus), a large
freshwater crustacean which is native to north-western USA,
but is now widely present as an invasive species in North
America, Japan and western Europe.
Aims
Crayish have been found to be able rework luvial substrates,
particular by winnowing ine material from between coarse
grains (Statzner et al., 2000; 2003; Creed and Reed, 2004;
Usio and Townsend, 2004). The inluence of abiotic and
biotic interactions on substrate reworking by crayish has
also been studied (Statzner and Peltret, 2006; Statzner and
Sagnes, 2008). The results presented here are part of a larger
research project which aims to build on these previous studies
by quantifying the impact of signal crayish (P. leniusculus)
on luvial gravel substrates and to determine how crayish
alter the geomorphic, hydraulic and sedimentary processes
operating at the substratum surface. The speciic objectives
of this paper are: (1) to establish whether crayish can alter
the micro-topography of gravel substrates and determine the
mechanisms of disturbance; (2) to determine whether crayish
can rework substrates that have been structured by lowing
water (i.e. water-worked substrates); and (3) to determine
whether gravel stability is modiied due to the reworking of
the substratum by crayish.
Methodology
Overview
A series of experiments was undertaken in a laboratory
lume to study the impact of crayish on the topography of
gravel substrates. Narrowly-graded gravel was placed in an
experimental section of the lume and screeded lat. In half
of the experiments, the substratum surface was loose with
random arrangements of gravel (series 1) and in the other