THE SMOKING AND HEALTH ISSUE IN
NEWSPAPERS: INFLUENCE OF REGIONAL
ECONOMIES, THE TOBACCO INSTITUTE
AND NEWS OBJECTIVITY
By C. Kevin Swisher and Stephen D. Reese
This study examined the possible influence on newspoper
coverage of tobocco-related issues by the importance of tobocco in
the somple newspapers' economy, the public relations activities of
the Tobocco Institute and the importance that joumalists place on
providing an objective balance of points of views in stories.
Modest differences in "support" of tobacco were found in headline
slont ond m use of tobacco industry sources in major smoking-
related stories when newspapers of different regions were
compared. Storie.^ show how the tobacco industry attempts to take
advantage of reporters desire to balance stories, but with only
limited regional differences.
On January 11. 1964. Surgeon General Luther Terry confirmed
what doctors and scientists had knovim for years: smoking was a primary
cause of lung cant^er and was strongly linked to emphysema and heart
disease.^
Since then, thousands of studies have only strengthened the case
against cigarettes. Government estimates place the annual smoking-
related death toll in the United States at 390,000 — or more than one in
six deaths from all causes.^ Such figures prompted former Surgeon
General C. Everett Koop tu label smoking "the chief, single avoidable
cause of death in our society.""'
Nevertheless, 49 million Americans smoke.^ and millions more
have only a superficial understanding of the health risks involved.^
Given this state of affairs, many have accused the mass media of shirking
their responsibility to communicate smoking risks. Certainly media
Kevin Swislier earnt^d his master's degree in tlie University of Texos Department of
Journalism where Stephen Reese is ass€>ciate professor. The authors thank Gale
Wiley of the Texas Department of lournalism for help witli tl\e VU/TEXT data hase
system. This study was presented at tlie in91 AEJMC conferi-nrt- in Boston.
JoumaUsm
Quarterly
Vol. 69, No. 4
Winter 1992
987-1000
©1992 AEJMC
SMOKING AND HEALTH COVERAGE IN NEWSPAPERS 987